Album/Song Rankings (10,840 views)

[Baronessa]

I just completed my second Bob Dylan dive, so I thought this would be as good an excuse as any to bring this thread back.

Bob Dylan:
1. Blood on the Tracks
2. Blonde on Blonde
3. Time Out of Mind
4. The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan
5. Highway 61 Revisited
6. Bringing It All Back Home
7. The Basement Tapes
8. Rough and Rowdy Ways
9. Oh Mercy
10. "Love and Theft"
11. John Wesley Harding
12. Nashville Skyline
13. Desire
14. Together Through Life
15. Modern Times
16. Another Side of Bob Dylan
17. The Times They Are A-Changin'
18. Infidels
19. World Gone Wrong
20. Good as I Been to You
21. Planet Waves
22. Under the Red Sky
23. Tempest
24. Street-Legal
25. Slow Train Coming
26. New Morning
27. Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid
28. Bob Dylan
29. Shadows in the Night
30. Triplicate
31. Empire Burlesque
32. Fallen Angels
33. Knocked Out Loaded
34. Down in the Groove
35. Christmas in the Heart
36. Saved
37. Self Portrait
38. Shot of Love
39. Dylan

[Seb]

(Recently updated)
The Strokes:
1. Is This It 
2. Room On Fire
3. The New Abnormal 
4. First Impressions Of Earth 
5. Comedown Machine
6. Angles 
7. Future Present Past (EP but whatever)

The White Stripes:
1. Elephant
2. Icky Thump 
3. The White Stripes 
4. De Stijl
5. White Blood Cells
6. Get Behind Me Satan

Lust For Youth:
1. Lust For Youth
2. Solar Flare 
3. International 
4. Growing Seeds 
5. Compassion
6. Perfect View 
7. Pomegranate 
8. Saluting Rome (EP) 
9. *Insert their pre-2011 material here* 

I'd do Fiona Apple but that would just be her discography in chronological order

[Baronessa]

Jul 15, 2020 9:12:25 GMT Seb said:

The White Stripes:
1. Elephant
2. Icky Thump
3. White Blood Cells
4. The White Stripes
5. De Stijl
6. Get Behind Me Satan

I've always been weird in that Get Behind Me Satan is my favourite by the White Stripes. :) It's honestly one of my favourite albums full stop.

[Seb]

Jul 19, 2020 13:39:56 GMT Baronessa said:

Jul 15, 2020 9:12:25 GMT Seb said:

The White Stripes:
1. Elephant
2. Icky Thump
3. White Blood Cells
4. The White Stripes
5. De Stijl
6. Get Behind Me Satan

I've always been weird in that Get Behind Me Satan is my favourite by the White Stripes. It's honestly one of my favourite albums full stop.

I liked it quite a bit. I enjoy all of The White Stripes' albums. I guess it was just a little lacking for me? I enjoy what they did without many electric guitars but some moments in the album just passed me by. A lot of great songs on it though (The Nurse is one of my favorites, idk if that's a hot take or not)

[halloweenjack95]

George Michael

Albums:

1. Listen without Prejudice Vol.1
2. Older
3. Faith
4. Patience
5. Songs from the last Century


Songs:

1. Mothers Pride
2. Jesus to a Child
3. Praying for Time
4. One more Try
5. Freedom
6. Fastlove
7. Kissing a fool
8. Through
9. Waiting (reprise)
10. Star people

[Baronessa]

Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds:
1. Abattoir Blues / The Lyre of Orpheus
2. Skeleton Tree
3. Henry's Dream
4. The Good Son
5. Let Love In
6. Murder Ballads
7. Your Funeral ... My Trial
8. Tender Prey
9. Push the Sky Away
10. Ghosteen
11. No More Shall We Part
12. The Boatman's Call
13. Kicking Against the Pricks
14. Dig, Lazarus, Dig!!!
15. The Firstborn Is Dead
16. From Her to Eternity
17. Nocturama

[Dark Star]

Rush
1. Moving Pictures
2. A Farewell to Kings
3. Permanent Waves
4. Hemispheres
5. Clockwork Angels
6. Power Windows
7. Grace Under Pressure
8. Signals
9. Counterparts
10. 2112
11. Fly by Night
12. Caress of Steel
13. Test for Echo
14. Rush
15. Presto
16. Roll the Bones
17. Snakes and Arrows
18. Vapor Trails
19. Hold Your Fire

Songs
1. The Spirit of Radio
2. Limelight
3. The Pass
4. Vital Signs
5. Marathon
6. Bastille Day
7. The Body Electric
8. Force Ten
9. How It Is
10. Entre Nous

[queenfan11]

Metallica:
1. Master of Puppets (5/5)
2. Ride the Lightning (5/5)
3. ...And Justice For All (5/5)
4. Hardwired...to Self Destruct (5/5)
5. Kill 'Em All (4.5/5)
6. Metallica (4.5/5)
7. Death Magnetic (4.5/5)
8. ReLoad (4/5)
9. Load (4/5)
10. St. Anger (4/5)

Parenthesis are the grades i'd give them in stars. 

[Deleted]

Queen:
1. Night At The Opera
2. Queen II
3. A Day At The Races
4. Queen
5. Sheer Heart Attack
6. News Of The World
7. A Kind Of Magic
8. Innuendo
9. Jazz
10. The Game
11. The Works
12. The Miracle
13. Made In Heaven
14. Hot Space (one of their worst actual studio albums. Yuck.)
15. Flash Gordon (not a fan of it at all.. )

[Baronessa]

A Kind of Magic doesn't get enough flak tbh.

[ellie]

Hot Space is a top 8 queen album


Adding the objective Queen album ranking:
1. Queen II if you disagree then you're like 5 years old
2. A Day at the Races 
3. News of the World
4. Queen
5. A Night at the Opera 
6. Jazz
7. The Game
8. Hot Space
9. Innuendo
10. Sheer Heart Attack
11. The Works 
12. Made In Heaven
13. A Kind of Magic
14. Flash Gordon  I'm only including this to express how much I hate the last one cause this really doesn't count 
15. The Miracle
 If you disagree then idk what's wrong with you

[halloweenjack95]

The Rolling Stones

Albums:

1. Exile on Main St.
2. Beggars Banquet
3. Let it Bleed
4. Sticky Fingers
5. Goat's Head Soup
6. Aftermath (UK)
7. Some Girls
8. Their Satanic Majestic Request
9. It's only Rock'n Roll
10. Between the Buttons

Songs:

1. Shine a Light
2. I've got the Blues
3. Winter
4. Gimme Shelter
5. Out of Time
6. No expectations
7. You can't always get what you want
8. Angie
9. Wild Horses
10. Lady Jane
11. Time waits for no One
12. 100 Years Ago
13. Street Fighting Man
14. Let it Loose
15. Some Girls
16. Fool to Cry
17. Sympathy for the Devil
18. 2000 Light Years from Home
19. Coming Down again
20. Rocks off

[ellie]

I was too lazy to write all this out and also I wanted it to be easier to edit as I made this in like 30 minutes based primarily off how I remembered the songs being and also really only looked at her first 3 albums but yeah this is the objectively correct list

P.S. I don’t know if Spotify playlist automatically embed so I guess we’ll see

edit: oh yeah also it’s ordered best to less best and the number of songs means nothing It’s just the amount I chose to put in this since I initially just meant it to a playlist of my favorites and then I decided to post it here cause frick it Dude 

[halloweenjack95]

The Beach Boys

Albums:

1. Pet Sounds
2. Sunflower
3. Surfs Up
4. Wild Honey
5. Today!
6. Summer Days
7. Love you
8. Surfer Girl
9. Shut Down
10. Smiley Smile ( I excluded the Smile Sessions but it would share a spot with Wild Honey or even surfs up)

Songs:

1. Dont Talk (Put your Hand on my shoulder)
2. Surf's Up
3. I just wasnt made for these times
4. Forever
5. This Whole World
6. Good Vibrations
7. Dont Worry Baby
8. In my Room
9. Oh, Caroline no
10. All I wanna do

[Baronessa]

Taylor Swift:
1. evermore
2. 1989
3. Red
4. folklore
5. Taylor Swift
6. Speak Now
7. Lover
8. reputation
9. Fearless

First impressions. Haters gonna hate, hate, hate...

['S]

Toilet Swish:
1. Red
2. 1989
3. evermore
4. Speak Now
5. folklore
6. reputation
7. Fearless
8. Lover
9. Taylor Swift

Idr when my first impressions were.

Bonus:

Best lyric - 'Hey Stephen, why are people always leaving? '

..........................................................................................................

Carpentarius:
1. A Song for You
2. Close to You
3. Passage
4. Carpenters
5. Made in America
6. Horizon
7. Christmas Portrait
8. Now & Then
9. A Kind of Hush
10. Lovelines
11. Voice of the Heart
12. Ticket to Ride
13. An Old Fashioned Christmas
14. As Time Goes By

^ Hottake mushrooms, I know

..........................................................................................................

Catríona Bushcraft:

1. Hounds of Love

2. Never for Ever

3. The Kick Inside

4. The Dreaming

5. Lionheart

6. The Red Shoes

7. Aerial

8. The Sensual World

9. Director's Cut

10. 50 Words for Snow

^Obviously The Whole Story beats 'em all anyway, yes.

[Batfleck]

Depeche Mode:
1. Violator (10/10)
2. Music for the Masses (10/10)
3. Black Celebration (10/10)
4. Songs of Faith and Devotion (9/10)
5. Playing the Angel (9/10)
6. Ultra (8/10)
7. Some Great Reward (8/10)
8. Delta Machine (8/10)
9. Construction Time Again (8/10)
10. Speak & Spell (7/10)
11. Exciter (6/10)
12. Sounds of the Universe (5/10)
13. A Broken Frame (4/10)
14. Spirit (3/10)

Trivium:
1. Shogun (10/10)
2. In Waves (10/10)
3. The Sin and the Sentence (9/10)
4. Ascendancy (9/10)
5. What the Dead Men Say (8/10)
6. Ember to Inferno (8/10)
7. Silence in the Snow (8/10)
8. The Crusade (7/10)
9. Vengeance Falls (7/10)

[Dark Star]

Genesis
1. A Trick of the Tail
2. The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
3. Selling England by the Pound
4. Invisible Touch
5. Duke
6. Foxtrot
7. Wind and Wuthering
8. Abacab
9. Nursery Crime
10. And Then There Were Three
11. Trespass
12. We Can't Dance
13. Genesis
14. From Genesis to Revelation
15. Calling All Stations

Songs
1. Mama
2. In The Cage
3. Home By The Sea
4. Supper's Ready
5. Hold on My Heart
6. Squonk
7. Land of Confusion
8. The Cinema Show
9. Dancing with the Moonlit Knight
10. Abacab
11. In Too Deep
12. Tonight, Tonight, Tonight
13. Follow You, Follow Me
14. Ripples
15. I Know What I Like

[Dark Star]

Phil Collins (solo)
1. No Jacket Required
2. ...But Seriously
3. Face Value
4. Hello, I Must Be Going
5. Both Sides
6. Dance Into The Light
7. Testify

[halloweenjack95]

Pearl Jam Albums:

1. Vitalogy 
2. Ten
3. Vs
4. Yield
5. No Code 
6. Binural 
7. Gigaton
8. Backspacer 
9. Lightning Bolt
10. Pearl Jam aka Avocado
11. Rio act 


Songs:

1. Release
2. Black 
3. Nothingman
4. Blood 
5. Do the Evolution 
6. Spin the Black Circle 
7. Once
8. Daughter 
9. Even flow 
10. Better Man

[Baronessa]

Type O Negative:
1. World Coming Down
2. Bloody Kisses
3. October Rust
4. Dead Again
5. Life Is Killing Me
6. Slow, Deep and Hard

What a band; it's taken me too long to get into them.

[Batfleck]

Paradise Lost:

1. Draconian Times
2. Icon
3. The Plague Within
4. Shades of God
5. Gothic
6. Obsidian
7. Symbol of Life
8. One Second
9. Host
10. In Requiem
11. Faith Divides Us, Death Unites Us
12. Tragic Idol
13. Medusa
14. Lost Paradise
15. Paradise Lost
16. Believe in Nothing

[Seb]

Depeche Mode:
1. Violator
2. Music for the Masses
3. Songs of Faith and Devotion 
4. Some Great Reward 
5. Black Celebration
6. Ultra 
7. Playing the Angel
8. Speak & Spell
9. Delta Machine
10. Construction Time Again 
11. Sounds of the Universe
12. Exciter
13. A Broken Frame
14. Spirit

Vampire Weekend:
Modern Vampires Of The City
Contra 
Father Of The Bride 
Vampire Weekend

Kanye West:
1. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy 
2. Late Registration 
3. The College Dropout 
4. 808's and Heartbreak 
5. Graduation 
6. Yeezus
7. Kids See Ghosts
8. Donda
9. Watch The Throne
10. The Life of Pablo
11. Cruel Summer
12. Jesus Is King
13. ye

[Baronessa]

Motörhead:
1. Orgasmatron
2. Overkill
3. Motörizer
4. Ace of Spades
5. Bastards
6. We Are Motörhead
7. Aftershock
8. 1916
9. Inferno
10. Bad Magic
11. Overnight Sensation
12. Sacrifice
13. Another Perfect Day
14. Iron Fist
15. Kiss of Death
16. Rock 'n' Roll
17. The Wörld is Yours
18. Bomber
19. March ör Die
20. Motörhead
21. Hammered
22. Snake Bite Love

No Sleep 'Til Hammersmith would be #2 if it was a studio album.

[Henny Macc]

Aug 29, 2021 19:15:01 GMT Baronessa said:

Type O Negative:
1. World Coming Down
2. Bloody Kisses
3. October Rust
4. Dead Again
5. Life Is Killing Me
6. Slow, Deep and Hard

What a band; it's taken me too long to get into them.

I'll piggyback off of this one, though mine is quite different:

1. Dead Again

2. Bloody Kisses

3. Life Is Killing Me (severely underrated album imo)

4. October Rust

5. World Coming Down

6. Slow, Deep and Hard