Daniel Gildenlöw (8,661 views)

[Zedd Squared]

Member Of: Reality (1984-1991), Pain of Salvation (1991-present), The Flower Kings (2002-2004), The Sea Within (2018-present)
Voice Type: Baritone
Vocal Range: A1-A5

High Notes:

A5 ("Dea Pecuniae", "Disco Queen", "Eleven", "Idiocracy", "Immigrant Song" Montreal 2006, "Reconciliation", "Repent", "The Sum of Damage Done", "Threnody for an Endling", "Used")
G♯5 ("! (Foreword)", "The Big Machine", "Fandango", "Repent", "Revival")
G5 ("Break Darling Break", "Cribcaged", "Dedication", "Eleven", "Enter Rain", "The Final Surprise", "Gone", "Hallelujah" de Bosuil 2009, "Idioglossia", "In the Flesh", "Let Me Live", "Misty Mountain Hop" Montreal 2006, "Morning on Earth", "Mortar Grind", "Nightmist", "The Rain Song" Montreal 2006, "Scarsick", "Threnody for an Endling", "Unfuture", "Unknowing")
F♯5 ("! (Foreword)", "Angels" Budapest 2001, "Beyond the Mirror", "Ending Theme" Aschaffenburg 2012, "Handful of Nothing", "Healing Now", "Melissa's Friend", "No Way", "Of Dust")
F5 ("Angels" Budapest 2001, "Ashes", "Beyond the Pale", "Dea Pecuniae", "Disco Queen", "Diffidentia (Breaching the Core)", "Fandango", "Flame to the Moth", "If You Wait", "King of Loss", "Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova)", "Melissa's Friend", "The Perfect Element", "Sleeping Under the Stars", "Softly She Cries", "Thorn Clown", "Threnody for an Endling", "Timeweaver's Tale", "A Trace of Blood, "Where It Hurts", "Winning a War")
E5 ("Adam & Eve", "All My Fault", "Chain Sling" Original + Falling Home, "Conditioned", "Darkness of Mine", "Dazed and Confused" Montreal 2006, "Far Away from Here", "Fast Lane", "The Fifth Extinction", "The Final Surprise", "Flame to the Moth" Original + Falling Home, "Hallelujah" Amsterdam 2009, "He Will Die", "Houses of the Holy" Montreal 2006, "In the Flesh", "Inside", "Linoleum" Falling Home, "Misty Mountain Hop" Montreal 2006, "Morning on Earth", "Mrs. Modern Mother Mary", "New Year's Eve" Amsterdam 2007, "The Perfect Element", "The Rain Song" Montreal 2006, "Revival", "The Rover" Montreal 2006, "Scarsick", "The Sixth Extinction", "Species", "Stress", "To the Shoreline" Original + Falling Home, "A Trace of Blood", "Used", "A Vampire's View", "Waking Every God", "Water", "Winning a War", "Working Class Hero" Italy 2003, "Yellow Raven")
E♭5 ("The Big Machine", "Darkness of Mine", "Fast Lane", "Immigrant Song" Montreal 2006, "Into the Blue", "Linoleum" Falling Home, "Of Dust", "Tell Me You Don't Know", "Timeweaver's Tale")
D5 ("Adam & Eve", "America", "Beyond the Pale", "Black Hills", "Chain Sling", "Conditioned", "Cribcaged", "Dazed and Confused" Montreal 2006, "Dea Pecuniae", "The Deeper Cut", "Devil's Playground", "Ending Theme", "An Eye for an Eye for an Eye", "Fast Lane", "Healing Now", "Heaven on Their Minds", "Idioglossia", "I'm Afraid", "Innocence", "Introspection 2.0", "Iter Impius", "Jump Off This Train", "King of Loss", "Let Me Live", "Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova)", "Morning on Earth", "Mortar Grind", "Mrs. Modern Mother Mary", "Nihil Morari", "Paradox", "The Physics of Gridlock", "The Rain Song" Montreal 2006, "Reconciliation", "The Rover" Montreal 2006, "Sisters", "Spitfall" Falling Home, "The Sum of Damage Done", "To the Shoreline", "Where It Hurts")
C♯5 ("Accelerator", "Angels" Budapest 2001, "Far Away from Here", "Healing Now", "Houses of the Holy" Montreal 2006, "I'm Afraid", "Immigrant Song" Montreal 2006, "In the Flesh", "Inside", "Newborn Race", "Of Salt", "Restless Boy", "Rollin' the Dice", "Rope Ends", "Softly She Cries", "Species", "Stress", "To the End")
C5 ("! (Foreword)", "1979" Falling Home, "All My Fault", "Beyond the Mirror", "Black Hills", "Dea Pecuniae", "Ending Theme", "Fandango", "Far Away from Here", "Fast Lane", "Full Throttle Tribe", "Gone", "Hallelujah" Amsterdam 2009, "Healing Now", "Heartbreaker" Montreal 2006, "Holy Diver", "I Die", "If This Is the End", "If You Wait", "I'm Afraid", "Iter Impius", "Keep Breathing", "Kingdom of Loss", "Let Me Live", "Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova)", "Linoleum", "Livin' Lovin' Maid (She's Just a Woman)" Montreal 2006, "Martius/Nauticus II", "Misty Mountain Hop" Montreal 2006, "New Year's Eve", "New York, New York" Webster Hall 2017, "Nihil Morari", "The Perfect Element", "Reasons", "Revival", "Scarsick", "Second Love", "The Song Remains the Same" Montreal 2006, "Sleeping Under the Stars", "Species", "Spitfall", "The Sum of Damage Done", "Toy Warehouse", "Undertow", "Unfuture", "Winning a War")
B4 ("Accelerator", "America", "Ashes of Dawn", "Cosmic Circus", "Curiosity", "Darkness of Mine", "Dazed and Confused" Montreal 2006, "The Deeper Cut", "Devil's Playground", "Dust in the Wind", "An Eye for an Eye for an Eye", "Falling Home", "Full Throttle Tribe", "Gone", "Her Voices", "Idiocracy", "Idioglossia", "Innocence", "Inside", "Introspection 2.0", "Iter Impius", "Jump Off This Train", "Keen to a Fault", "King of Loss", "Kingdom of Loss", "Let Me Live", "Livin' Lovin' Maid (She's Just a Woman)" Montreal 2006, "Meaningless", "Mrs. Modern Mother Mary", "Night's Descending", "No Way", "Of Two Beginnings", "On a Tuesday", "Paradox", "People Passing By", "Perfect Day", "Pilgrim", "Plains of Dawn", "Reasons", "Reconciliation", "Revival", "Rope Ends", "The Rover" Montreal 2006, "She Likes to Hide", "Shore Serenity", "The Sixth Extinction", "The Song Remains the Same" Montreal 2006, "Starlight Man", "Tell Me You Don't Know", "They Know My Name", "This Heart of Mine (I Pledge)", "Timelines", "To the End", "To the Shoreline", "Unknowing", "Used", "A Vampire's View", "Waking Every God", "Working Class Hero" Italy 2003)
B♭4 ("Adam & Eve", "Beyond the Pale", "Black Hills", "Break Darling Break", "Darkness of Mine", "Dea Pecuniae", "Disco Queen", "Heaven on Their Minds", "I Die", "Diffidentia (Breaching the Core)", "Disco Queen", "Fast Lane", "Gone", "If You Wait", "Imago (Homines Partus)", "King of Loss", "Melissa's Friend", "Mortar Grind", "Never Learn to Fly", "No Way", "Of Dust", "Panther", "Pilgrim", "The Roaring Silence", "Rollin' the Dice", "Softly She Cries", "Threnody for an Endling", "Tongue of God", "Unfuture", "Used", "A Vampire's View", "Wait")
A4 ("! (Foreword)", "1979", "Accelerator", "Adam & Eve", "Age of Shadows", "America", "Ashes", "Ashes of Dawn", "Beyond the Mirror", "The Big Machine", "Chain Sling", "Come Down in Time" Italy 2003, "Conditioned", "Cribcaged", "Curiosity", "The Deeper Cut", "Devil's Playground", "Eleven", "Enter Rain", "An Eye for an Eye for an Eye", "Fast Lane", "Fields of Gold" Eskilstuna 2015, "Flame to the Moth", "Hallelujah" Amsterdam 2009, "Handful of Nothing", "Heaven on Their Minds", "Heartbreaker" Montreal 2006, "He Will Die", "Her Voices", "Houses of the Holy" Montreal 2006, "Idiocracy", "If This Is the End", "I'm Afraid", "In the Flesh", "Inside Out", "Into the Blue", "Introspection 2.0", "Jump Off This Train", "Kingdom of Loss", "Linoleum", "Mrs. Modern Mother Mary", "Nauticus (Drifting)", "Never Learn to Fly", "New Year's Eve", "New York, New York" Webster Hall 2017, "Newborn Race", "Night's Descending", "Omni", "Paradox", "People Passing By", "The Physics of Gridlock", "Reasons", "Reconciliation", "Scarsick", "Second Love", "She Likes to Hide", "Silent Gold", "Sisters", "Species", "Spitfall", "Starlight Man", "Stress", "The Sum of Damage Done", "This Heart of Mine (I Pledge)", "Through the Distance", "Time", "Timelines", "Timeweaver's Tale", "Tongue of God", "Toy Warehouse", "A Trace of Blood", "To the Shoreline", "A Vampire's View", "The Void", "Wait", "Water", "Where It Hurts", "Winning a War", "Working Class Hero" Italy 2003, "Yellow Raven")
G♯4 ("Denise", "Driver's Seat", "Icon", "Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova)", "No Way", "Of Salt", "The Passing Light of Day", "Plains of Dawn", "Rollin' the Dice", "Save Me from My Destiny", "Sea Without", "The Sixth Extinction", "The Taming of a Beast", "They Know My Name", "Tell Me You Don't Know", "Time", "Timeweaver's Tale", "Waking Every God")
G4 ("Cribcaged", "Dedication", "Driver's Seat", "Dust in the Wind", "Enter Rain", "Fandango", "Full Throttle Tribe", "Holy Diver", "Home", "Idioglossia", "Inside Out", "Keen to a Fault", "King of Loss", "Leaving Entropia (Epilogue)", "New York, New York" Webster Hall 2017, "Nightmist", "On a Tuesday", "Panther", "Pappa", "The Passing Light of Day", "Plains of Dawn", "Reconciliation", "Repent", "Road Salt", "The Roaring Silence", "Scarsick", "Sea Without", "Silent Gold", "Small Things" Eskilstuna 2021, "This Heart of Mine (I Pledge)", "Thorn Clown", "To the End", "Toy Warehouse", "The Void", "Where Are You Going?", "Working Class Hero" Italy 2003, "Yellow Raven")

Low Notes:

D3 ("Beyond the Pale", "Come Down in Time" Italy 2003, "Dedication", "The Deeper Cut", "Disco Queen", "Driver's Seat", "An Eye for an Eye for an Eye", "Fandango", "Heaven on Their Minds", "Her Voices", "Imago (Homines Partus)", "Innocence", "Keen to a Fault", "Martius/Nauticus II", "Night's Descending", "Nihil Morari", "The Perfect Element", "Plains of Dawn", "The Roaring Silence", "Song for the Innocent", "Timeweaver's Tale", "Undertow", "Unknowing", "The Void", "Wait", "Water", "Working Class Hero" Italy 2003)
C♯3 ("Angels" Budapest 2001, "Animae Partus", "Ashes of Dawn", "Circles", "Fields of Gold" Eskilstuna 2015, "Flame to the Moth", "Her Voices", "Panther", "Restless Boy", "Rollin' the Dice", "Rope Ends", "Softly She Cries", "Time")
C3 ("America", "The Big Machine", "Break Darling Break", "Come Down in Time" Italy 2003, "Dea Pecuniae", "Diffidentia (Breaching the Core)", "Eleven", "Far Away from Here", "Hallelujah" Eskilstuna 2021, "Heaven on Their Minds", "Holy Diver", "I Die", "Idiocracy", "In the Flesh", "Keep Breathing", "Kingdom of Loss", "Leaving Entropia (Epilogue)", "Martius/Nauticus II", "Meaningless", "New Year's Eve", "Oblivion Ocean", "The Passing Light of Day", "The Perfect Element", "Plains of Dawn", "Sisters", "Small Things" Eskilstuna 2021, "This Heart of Mine (I Pledge)", "Unfuture", "Wait", "What She Means to Me", "Where It Hurts")
B2 ("! (Foreword)", "Cribcaged", "The Deeper Cut", "An Eye for an Eye for an Eye", "Full Throttle Tribe", "Handful of Nothing", "I Die", "If This Is the End", "Keen to a Fault", "Kingdom of Loss", "Meaningless", "Morning on Earth", "Never Learn to Fly", "Oblivion Ocean", "Of Two Beginnings", "On a Tuesday", "Perfect Day", "Reasons", "Revival", "Save Me from My Destiny", "She Likes to Hide", "Sleeping Under the Stars", "Working Class Hero" Italy 2003)
B♭2 ("America", "Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova)", "Panther", "People Passing By", "Rollin' the Dice", "Softly She Cries", "Thorn Clown", "Unfuture", "A Vampire's View")
A2 ("! (Foreword)", "All My Fault", "America", "Beyond the Mirror", "Black Hills", "Chain Sling", "Conditioned", "Cribcaged", "Enter Rain", "Fandango", "Fast Lane", "The Fifth Extinction", "Flame to the Moth", "Handful of Nothing", "Idiocracy", "In the Flesh", "Iter Impius", "Kingdom of Loss", "Morning on Earth", "Mortar Grind", "Mrs. Modern Mother Mary", "Nauticus (Drifting)", "New Year's Eve", "On a Tuesday", "The Physics of Gridlock", "Pilgrim", "Reconciliation", "Repent", "Scarsick", "Sisters", "Sleeping Under the Stars", "Small Things" Eskilstuna 2021, "Species", "The Sum of Damage Done", "Stress" Original + Falling Home, "Threnody for an Endling", "Timelines", "Water")
G♯2 ("Black Hills", "Diffidentia (Breaching the Core)", "The Fifth Extinction", "Full Throttle Tribe", "Inside", "Nightmist", "Panther", "Perfect Day", "Time", "Winning a War")
G2 ("Adam & Eve", "America", "Break Darling Break", "Dea Pecuniae", "Disco Queen", "Enter Rain", "Falling Home", "Far Away from Here", "He Will Die", "Help Me Make It Through the Night", "If This Is the End", "Iter Impius", "Linoleum", "Mrs. Modern Mother Mary", "Nauticus (Drifting)", "Nihil Morari", "The Passing Light of Day", "The Roaring Silence", "Sisters", "Species", "Spitfall", "Stress", "Threnody for an Endling", "Timeweaver's Tale", "To the Shoreline", "Tongue of God", "Unfuture", "Used", "Winning a War")
F♯2 ("Accelerator", "America", "Beneath the Waves", "Beyond the Mirror", "Devil's Playground", "Disco Queen", "Ending Theme", "Healing Now", "Her Voices", "In the Flesh" Progpower USA 2002, "Of Two Beginnings", "On a Tuesday", "Rope Ends", "Stress" Falling Home, "The Taming of a Beast", "Thorn Clown")
F2 ("Ashes", "The Big Machine", "King of Loss", "The Physics of Gridlock", "The Sum of Damage Done", "This Heart of Mine (I Pledge)", "A Vampire's View")
E2 ("All My Fault", "Ashes", "Flame to the Moth", "Gone", "Idioglossia", "In the Flesh", "Jump Off This Train", "Keen to a Fault", "Leaving Entropia (Epilogue)", "Melissa's Friend", "Never Learn to Fly", "Nightmist", "Plains of Dawn", "Shore Serenity", "Spitfall", "The Taming of a Beast", "Timelines", "To the Shoreline" Falling Home, "Tongue of God", "A Trace of Blood", "Undertow", "Waking Every God", "Winning a War")
E♭2 ("Diffidentia (Breaching the Core)", "Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova)", "Of Dust")
D2 ("Dedication", "Ending Theme", "Enter Rain", "Imago (Homines Partus)", "Innocence", "Iter Impius" Essen 2013, "Moving On" Eskilstuna 2021, "Nauticus (Drifting)", "The Perfect Element", "The Physics of Gridlock", "Spitfall" Falling Home, "Threnody for an Endling", "Undertow")
C♯2 ("Of Dust", "Rollin' the Dice")
C2 ("Disco Queen", "Imago (Homines Partus)", "Innocence", "Lilium Cruentus (Deus Nova)")
A1 ("Ashes", "Beyond the Pale", "Unfuture")

The key characteristics of Daniel Gildenlöw's singing that come to mind are emotion, expression, athleticism, and versatility. Whether bringing down the roof with gritty belting or intoning a ballad with utmost fragility, his commitment to doing justice to a song is unwavering. As the face of Swedish progressive metal/rock icons Pain of Salvation, Gildenlöw is the rare prog singer whose chops match the instrumentalists in his band (which funnily enough, also includes himself) and is continually pushing his voice and music in unexpected directions. This rare combination of musical virtuosity and artistic innovation is what makes him such an icon of modern progressive music.

Shout Outs: Thanks to BassSquared for notewatching the Hammer of the Gods Led Zeppelin tribute show and some additional odds and ends (such as the Heaven on Their Minds cover). Also thanks to 'S for cropping the picture.
..................................................................................
*Underlines mark notes in backing vocals or otherwise obscured in the song mix.
*Blue marks soft/disconnected falsetto notes.
*Green marks harsh screamed notes.
*Italics mark non-sung notes.

SPOILER: Click to show

{Questionable Notes}B♭5 ("Spitfall" ^[4], "Threnody for an Endling" ^[2])
G5 ("He Will Die" ^[2], "Toy Warehouse" ^[2])
D5 ("Her Voices" ^[1][3], "Inside Out" ^[1][3])
C♯5 ("Adam & Eve" ^[2], "Reasons" ^[1])
B4 ("Sea Without" ^[2])
G4 ("Love Supreme" ^[2])

C3 ("Beyond the Pale" ^[1])
B2 ("Her Voices" ^[1], "Night's Descending" ^[2])
B♭2 ("I Die" ^[1])
A2 ("1979" Falling Home ^[1], "Newborn Race" ^[1], "Revival" ^[4])
G♯2 ("People Passing By" ^[3], "Sleeping Under the Stars" ^[3])
G2 ("Break Darling Break" ^[1], "Morning on Earth" ^[1])
F♯2 ("Inside" ^[3], "Morning on Earth" ^[3], "Sea Without" ^[2], "To the End" ^[3], "Water" ^[3], Winning a War" ^[3])
F2 ("If This Is the End" ^[3], "The Perfect Element" ^[3], "Timeweaver's Tale" ^[3])
E2 ("Adam & Eve" ^[2], "Conditioned" ^[1], "Goodbye" ^[2], "Iter Impius" ^[1], "Kingdom of Loss" ^[3], "Linoleum" Falling Home ^[3], "On a Tuesday" ^[3], "Road Salt" ^[1], "Small Things" Eskilstuna 2021 ^[1], "The Void" ^[1])
E♭2 ("Stress" Falling Home ^[1])
D2 ("Deus Nova" ^[3], "Flame to the Moth" Falling Home ^[3], "Gone" ^[1])
C2 ("Dea Pecuniae" ^[2], "Panther" ^[4], "Spitfall" Falling Home ^[1])

.......................................................
[1] marks yelps and short trills in high range or anacrusis and short dips in low range.
[2] marks notes of questionable identity that cannot be confirmed to be the singer in question.
[3] marks non-melodic notes that don't have a significant enough pitch to warrant inclusion.
[4] marks notes that possess uncertain pitch or have been pitch-shifted.
[5] marks notes that do not fit the previous criteria but are not of a substantial enough quality to warrant counting towards the singer's range.

SPOILER: Click to show

{Album Ranges}Pain of Salvation

Entropia (1997): E2-G♯5
One Hour by the Concrete Lake (1998): E2-G♯5
The Perfect Element (2000): A1-D2-A5
Remedy Lane (2002): A1-D2-F♯2-G♯5
BE (2004): C2-F5-A5
Scarsick (2007): C2-D2-F♯2-A5
Linoleum (2009): E2-G5
Road Salt One (2010): C2-C♯2-G2-F♯5
Road Salt Two (2011): D2-F2-G2-A5
Falling Home (2014): C2-E2-E5
In the Passing Light of Day (2017): E2-C5
Panther (2020): A1-E2-G2-G5

The Flower Kings

Unfold the Future (2002): C♯2-F♯2-E♭5-E5
Adam & Eve (2004): E2-F2-E5

Genius: A Rock Opera

Episode 1: A Human Into Dreams' World (2002): E3-D5*
Episode 2: In Search of the Little Prince (2004): E2-E5*
Episode 3: The Final Surprise (2007): E2-G5

Ayreon

01011001 (2008): F♯2-G♯2-E5

The Sea Within

The Sea Within (2018): B2-B4-D5

*Marks albums where Gildenlöw only sings on 2-4 songs and therefore are not a proper representation of his vocal range capabilities at the time.

[falsetokaiba]

He sings lead vocals here from about 6:29-7:29, including some solid E2s and a soft C5 at the end. Then he does some harmonies with Mark Boals later and hits a backing E5 at about 8:14.

[jaredletoisbackagain]

When you have the time you should definitely listen through this. Got loads of significant stuff: www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzOT3dpZb00&ab_channel=ChingChink

[Zedd Squared]

Yeah I'm in the midst of redoing the thread from scratch atm but that is definitely on my list of things to check. I figured I should also go through some of the Transatlantic live appearances though it seems like he mostly does backing vocals there. It'll be a little while yet before the upload is ready but I've rechecked all the studio guest appearances, The Sea Within album, and all the PoS tracks up to and including Road Salt One thus far.

[jaredletoisbackagain]

I see the B1 from Of Dust has been removed again. Gonna have to argue for its existence once more.

[Zedd Squared]

I could add it to the spoiler box in the new thread but I seriously don't hear anything remotely near that pitch even at the timestamps indicated on the old thread. Most people I've talked to since then also don't hear it but it's divisive no doubt.

Oh also I did notewatch the new album and there are some A1s on Unfuture so that's fun.

[jaredletoisbackagain]

How are you listening to the song? CD? Streaming service? youtube video? I'd like to hear the exact version you've heard.

[Zedd Squared]

Most recently on Spotify but I've also used Youtube in the past. Generally speaking a note shouldn't be so inaudible that you can't make it out without a very specific audio setup though.

[Henny Macc]

Oct 3, 2020 16:22:02 GMT jaredletoisbackagain said:

I see the B1 from Of Dust has been removed again. Gonna have to argue for its existence once more.

Honestly I was relistening to that clip recently and I couldn't really hear it either. Maybe I'll try bugging MrToddington about isolating it though, if that'll help at all.

[Rodney Blazershorts]

FWIW I never heard the note, not even back on DigitalDreamDoor

[jaredletoisbackagain]

Back in those days the song was credited for a Bb1 from another part of the song.

But, even though the majority is against me I'm pretty confident, mainly because I read an interview with the band where they actually credit the song with the lowest note by Gildenlöw to date (and they even mentioned the specific note)

Probably gonna have to search far and wide for that interview though, but I'll do my best.

[Zedd Squared]

They might've just thought the Eb2s he sings in there sound the deepest of anything they'd heard him sing, I'm not sure if they were really pinpointing down exact pitch (though I suppose it's possible).

Does anybody know where that "unspecified live performance" of Inside with an F#5 comes from? Same with the song Angels from 2001 because I can't find either of those for this revised version of the OP.

Also this time I didn't hear any G5 in Martius/Nauticus II or the backing A5 in The Sum of Damage Done. Anybody got a timestamp for them?

[jaredletoisbackagain]

Daniel Gildenlöw is very aware of the pitches of his highs and lows. He's talked several times about specific pitches, so when he realised he hit his lowest note I'm not surprised he'd be aware of what it was.

youtu.be/BTx0CKbe2Yw This is the performance of Angels

[Zedd Squared]

Alright this thread is fully updated now! Or at least, I went back through everything. It's obviously still flawed and missing some live notes so feel free to point out things it's missing or suggest bolds you'd like to see.

[Henny Macc]

Another find from the old Jowox emails - turns out he takes the melody up to G5 in this version of "Hallelujah"!

[jowox2]

Hi,

Can someone pitch the notes in the chorus and at the end, awesome swedish singing from 1992 by Thomas Vikström in Candlemass song Where the runes still speak (also sings in Therion).
www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Fx8qBPgfrA

[jaredletoisbackagain]

www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTeoU34tXE&ab_channel=Agerops some good notes in this. The most significant are probably the lows in Cohen's Moving On, from 28:48

[Henny Macc]

Apr 16, 2021 8:57:15 GMT jowox2 said:

Hi,

Can someone pitch the notes in the chorus and at the end, awesome swedish singing from 1992 by Thomas Vikström in Candlemass song Where the runes still speak (also sings in Therion).
www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Fx8qBPgfrA

Holy moly, Jowox old friend - is that you again after all these years?? You might remember me as Tarantinomaniac from YouTube! That's actually remarkably coincidental timing - I had literally just been thinking about reaching out to you via email to find out if you still had any interest in notewatching these days!

Welcome back!  :joyful:

[Zedd Squared]

Apr 16, 2021 9:55:16 GMT jaredletoisbackagain said:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTeoU34tXE&ab_channel=Agerops some good notes in this. The most significant are probably the lows in Cohen's Moving On, from 28:48

Well it only took my nearly 5 months but I finally notewatched this performance. Some good notes in the first and last tracks otherwise nothing new, but a great sounding performance throughout either way. I have a few questions about that performance though:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTeoU34tXE&t=87
Countable E2 here?

www.youtube.com/watch?v=5JTeoU34tXE&t=1823s
Till 30:34 sums up this performance well - would we consider these D2s spoken or sung? It's a Leonard Cohen track so it's normal to be a bit in the middle there, but the general intent of his cadence is centered around that note more than I'd normally expect to hear for a spoken passage.

[jaredletoisbackagain]

Wouldn't count the E2 personally, and honestly don't know what I'd call the D2s.

[Smitty.]

i wouldn't count the E2 as well
also i'd probably mark the D2s as melodic

[rudesssolo]

Hi all, Pain of Salvation played a couple of days ago at a prog fest in Italy. Daniel's vocal performance was good.

Here you can find many of the songs they've played: www.youtube.com/@channelmax6267/videos

During "Ashes" at 3:41 ( youtu.be/ocexUWC6Plk?feature=shared&t=221 ) I can hear what seems to be a E5.

During "On a Tuesday" at 10:10 ( youtu.be/-4lmyI8xy3Y?feature=shared&t=608 ) there is another E5 (not present in the studio version).