StYoseph
Vocal Novice
Offline
Yellow Happy Sunny Days :D
Posts: 38
Likes: 22
Join Date: June 2024
Favourite singer: Billy Joel
|
Post by StYoseph on Sept 14, 2024 21:13:07 GMT
Lyric Baritone.
|
|
|
|
Post by mushymarionette on Sept 15, 2024 14:58:15 GMT
|
|
|
|
Post by mushymarionette on Nov 9, 2024 1:12:50 GMT
Bold one of the "Blood Sugar Sex Magik" lows!
|
|
|
|
Post by avi on Nov 11, 2024 1:49:28 GMT
Alright here's all the notes I've found that the thread doesn't have E5 ("Fire") D5 ("Fire", " Rock & Roll") C♯5 (" Did I Let You Know", " Rock & Roll") B♭4 ("Mini-Epic (Kill for Your Country)" live in Hyde Park 2004, " Rock & Roll") A4 ("Andaman & Nicobar", "Don't You Ever Leave" various live performances, " Flea Fly", "Leverage of Space" live in Hyde Park 2004, "Mommasan", " Sugar Sugar") G♯4 ("Little Miss Lover", "Mini-Epic (Kill for Your Country)" live in Hyde Park 2004) G4 ("Andaman & Nicobar", "Blender", "Fire", "Flea Fly", "Leverage of Space" live in Hyde Park 2004, "Mommasan", " Time") F♯4 ("Blender", "Fall Water", "Fire", "Flea Fly") F4 ("Funky Monks", "Little Miss Lover", "Tellin' a Lie", "This Velvet Glove", "Time") E4 ("Fall Water", "Fortune Faded", "Goldmine", "Leverage of Space" live in Hyde Park 2004, "Midnight", "Mini-Epic (Kill for Your Country)" live in Hyde Park 2004, "On the Bright Side", "Outer Space", "Time") D3 ("Fire", " Trouble in the Pub") C♯3 ("Castles Made of Sand") C3 (" Little Miss Lover") B2 (" Dance, Dance, Dance") B♭2 (" Did I Let You Know", "What It Is (AKA Nina's Song)") A2 ("Castles Made of Sand", " Fire") G♯2 (" Love of Your Life") G2 ("What It Is (AKA Nina's Song)") F♯2 ("Castles Made of Sand") Also Rolling Sly Stone should have the live in Hyde Park 2004 tag, the studio recording hasn't been heard. Lots of weird screams on Fire, I think this thread would count a black D5 and E5 from it due to the "soft falsetto" thing (awful way to categorize notes imo doesn't tell you anything about his actual range) with a questionable nonmelodic blue A5 [5] and questionable nonmelodic green G#5 [3], though maybe this thread would be okay with them, I doubt it. And for questionable notes, [3] nonmelodic C#2 in Castles Made of Sand as well. For the record, I wouldn't actually call the D5 and E5 black, but they would be by this thread's standard. Edit: Just found this falsetto Bb5 as well youtu.be/bA0mcRLeCag?t=193 |
|
|
|
Post by amadeusd on Nov 14, 2024 5:36:47 GMT
There is some seriously inconsistent Bluing/nonbluing going on...
|
|
|
|
Post by avi on Nov 14, 2024 18:26:12 GMT
Yeah we should talk about the falsetto classification of this thread. I sympathize with it, he definitely has a mixed voice but the line is really, really blurred. Like the Sir Psycho D5 definitely feels blue to me, but the unused take in the Funky Monks doc sounds totally black. But still it is very inconsistent, and ideally "soft falsetto" as a clarification is done away with for "falsetto", and like everything above C5 should be revisited
|
|
|
|
Post by amadeusd on Nov 14, 2024 19:01:28 GMT
Yeah we should talk about the falsetto classification of this thread. I sympathize with it, he definitely has a mixed voice but the line is really, really blurred. Like the Sir Psycho D5 definitely feels blue to me, but the unused take in the Funky Monks doc sounds totally black. But still it is very inconsistent, and ideally "soft falsetto" as a clarification is done away with for "falsetto", and like everything above C5 should be revisited Pretty much agree - and yeah, a demarcation between falsetto and soft falsetto might (even if, technically, slightly inaccurately) shore up a lot of that issue in the sense that like you could call the Your Eyes Girl G could conceivably be heard as modal (though, i think this is clearly the wrong conclusion) whereas the Scar Tissue A4s are inarguably 'soft' falsetto. Would probably remove the need for several arguments over how falsetto is assessed. |
|
|
|
Post by mushymarionette on Nov 14, 2024 19:50:41 GMT
Yeah we should talk about the falsetto classification of this thread. I sympathize with it, he definitely has a mixed voice but the line is really, really blurred. Like the Sir Psycho D5 definitely feels blue to me, but the unused take in the Funky Monks doc sounds totally black. But still it is very inconsistent, and ideally "soft falsetto" as a clarification is done away with for "falsetto", and like everything above C5 should be revisited Yeah, he has some screamed mixed voice things going in the early days but those are disconnected from the rest of his range and quite sporadic so it's complicated... I'd probably blue them myself since the contrast is so massive (something I'd also do with a similarly disconnected singer like Prince) but each to their own |
|
