Controversial Notes and Pitching Help (11,409 views)

[Baronessa]

Come to this thread to ask for a more collective take on a contested note or to ask for help pitching a difficult note. Although, if the singer you're asking about already has a thread we'd prefer it if you asked there, as to not clog this whole thing too much.

If your question was left unanswered, you may bump it only when it's fallen behind on the previous page. Keep it reasonable, folks.

[1999]

Before I start Chris Martin's thread i need to know how we feel about this C6 being included in the thread: link

[thatsnotcool33]

Jun 12, 2020 15:57:07 GMT mrrobot166 said:

www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsjLtKNLDNE  Are The Higher Notes Real?

Idk if it’s just me, but the upper end of his “range” sounds SUPER fake

[jaredletoisbackagain]

Definitely fake.

[Platypus]

FROM THE BILLY GIBBONS THREAD:

SPOILER: Click to show

{Questions about pitch}{Questions about pitch}

G4 or G5?

SPOILER: Click to show

{Questions about countability}{Questions about countability}

the dispute is between the bookended D5s

SPOILER: Click to show

{Questions about pitch AND Countability}{Questions about pitch AND Countability}

[Gilad]

So I'm about to put out the Adam Lambert thread, and I haven't found any notes under A2, except for this E2. I'm really on the fence cuz it's solid but it's quite a distance away and it's not as high quality as the rest of his range is.

[1999]

I wouldn't counted personally, It doesn't really have that strong of a pitch tbh. Quite airy as well.

[Henny Macc]

Dec 9, 2020 10:23:52 GMT Gilad said:

So I'm about to put out the Adam Lambert thread, and I haven't found any notes under A2, except for this E2. I'm really on the fence cuz it's solid but it's quite a distance away and it's not as high quality as the rest of his range is.

I'd count it as an italic note. Yes it's slightly underwhelming, but I don't think we would be questioning its inclusion if he had more notes in the F2-G♯2 range to fill the gap between it and his next-lowest.

Actually kinda surprised he still hasn't done anything else below A2 after all these years though  :surprised:

[Gilad]

I guess my argument is similar to the one people used against Sinatra's falsetto notes. It's just not up to the standard of his other notes. I don't think Lambert himself would want us to count that as part of his range.

[Gatr]

Alright, at long last, we've got a note with some controversy around it again

SPOILER: Click to show

{Note}

This E♭5 at the start here. When I originally posted my Chris Stapleton thread it seemed like the majority consensus was that it was Chris, though Gilad was arguing that it may have been Ed. Now with the new Bruno Mars thread up, it's being brought into question again, as kaji has brought up the possibility of it being Bruno. He and I seem to be more or less torn between Chris and Bruno, since it does sound very similar tonally to some notes from both singers around the same area. With all this considered, I thought this thread would be a good place to discuss it.

[Gilad]

Team Ed let's gooooooo

[Smitty.]

juast gonna say this while bruno has simallar notes i do not see it being him
butttttttt i could see it being ed
so i'm team ed too

[BAZanine]

I'm team Jacob.

[Captain Planet]

Well if the ginger women is lipsyncing it and she is the female Ed then surely it means he sung the note? Why the producers have Ed's woman lipsync the note if it wasn't him hitting it?

[tim]

If contributors could post evidence (links) showing why they think it's their suggested singer, it is likely a consensus could be reached more quickly.

The Ed Sheeran Hanover live recording of BLOW would indicate it's not him (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DmbH1W2m5tE).
See also the Prague gig: www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLPUdqTMLo4.

I'm not into Bruno Mars, but if someone can come up with a convincing example of a constricted bellow, from Bruno? :), at D5-E5, that might be persuasive. FWIW, I wasn't be persuaded by this: www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRwU4huYj-U

Chris has this in his arsenal: www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCFhhtlliKo - the holler at 16 secs in doesn't sound too far away tonally from the Eb5 in BLOW, more constriction in the BLOW note as it's higher.

But consider this: Bruno probably knows his way around a desk, it wouldn't be too much of a stretch that he has processed both Chris's and Ed's vocals (maybe all 3 of 'em!), perhaps mixed them in some way, and that's why it's proving tough to decide which guy it is...

Not sure how you'd then go about attributing the note to one of the singers, mind.

[Gatr]

Sorry, meant to come back to this sooner, but I've got some clips I can offer.

kaji offered these clips in a conversation in the Discord that we had the other night:

SPOILER: Click to show

{Team Bruno}




According to him, this clip has less distortion but a similar tone:

And these are some of the bold high notes from the Chris Stapleton thread that have a similar sound. I don't quite have anything from around the E♭5 area, but they're close enough, I think:

SPOILER: Click to show

{Team Chris}
This one sounds the closest in my opinion:

I don't have any clips for Ed, and I'm less inclined to think it's him anyway with everything that's been brought up here and elsewhere. At this point, I'm almost more convinced that it's Bruno, but I could really go either way.

[tim]

Thank you for the clips, Gatr and Kaji. Based on these clips, it would seem that the BLOW Eb5 is indeed more likely Bruno, and that is something I did not expect to write!

I hear Chris singing further back in his throat than Bruno does in these clips (Chris has more of an "ah" tone than Bruno's "or") which is what leads me to think it's more likely Bruno for the BLOW note.

Live and learn, thank you :smiley:

[Baronessa]

Allow me to shuffle the deck a little bit further by pointing out that there is another scream in "BLOW", at 3:06, which is far more likely to be Bruno to my ears as it has the appropriate amount of false cord distortion as showcased by all of the more distorted Bruno clips linked before.

I would argue that the only reason there is any confusion at all about it being Chris is that "BLOW" is mixed markedly differently from Chris' music, and it highlights more of his chainsaw rasp compared to the other clips showcased above (and of course that it's one of his higher notes, I don't think it affects the tone or the way the technique sounds however). From what I'm hearing Bruno's distortion technique does not 'click' with nearly the same amount of intensity as Chris' does.

[Gilad]

Well the Eb5 is still up for debate but the scream at 3:06 is definitely Ed to my ears. Firstly it comes right after his singing, and secondly he's got a similar sounding scream that's sampled a couple times in Remember the Name (e.g right at the end of the song). We've never really heard Ed use this hard-rock voice other than here, and just because there aren't instances of him doing it live doesn't mean the man doesn't experiment with his voice in the studio. I don't think it's fair to rule him out because he didn't do the scream during an acoustic performance of the song either.

Edit: Also from what I can tell, the screams that Chris uses tend to be weightier than the ones we hear in BLOW, so if everyone is against contributing the note to Ed I'd give it to Bruno

[Henny Macc]

Alright, here's another couple of notes to fight about:


There are screams at this timestamp and at 3:39 that we've been hearing differently on Discord. themriron2, Seb and Platypus seem to be hearing them as F♯5s, while Baronessa and I are hearing C♯5s with illusions up to F♯5 from the guitar. What say ye, TRP hivemind?

[aphelion]

Mar 30, 2021 17:28:28 GMT Henny Macc said:

SPOILER: Click to show

{Spoiler}Alright, here's another couple of notes to fight about:


There are screams at this timestamp and at 3:39 that we've been hearing differently on Discord. themriron2 , Seb and Platypus seem to be hearing them as F♯5s, while Baronessa and I are hearing C♯5s with illusions up to F♯5 from the guitar. What say ye, TRP hivemind?

I can tell why people would say both, but im inclined to say that its an F#5. It has a pretty clear note at the end of the scream which is definitely F#, before the guitar properly kicks in and reaches that higher register which would definitely create illusions if it were to play at the same time.

[Gilad]

I'm actually hearing E5s for those lol

[Gatr]

I can sort of hear it both ways between C♯ and F♯. If I had to pick one I'd probably be more inclined to say F♯ at the moment, but I'm not entirely sold on that tbh.

[tim]

Sounds like a Questionable Note to me. On the timestamped scream, I was tempted to say C#4 and every note from there on up. I ran it through an online spectrum analyser (https://academo.org/demos/spectrum-analyzer/) and it confirmed what my ears heard, a wash of frequencies in which you could legitimately hear any of the suggested pitches. Screenshot enclosed for reference, you can see the wash of frequencies that appears for the scream.

[slugger]

Not countable lol