Roger Taylor (18,046 views)

[innuendo]

I hear this note peaking at B♭5 ( youtu.be/mkBPm8Ps6ME?t=115 ). Thoughts and opinions?

[Puffin]

Feb 8, 2022 15:49:25 GMT innuendo said:

I hear this note peaking at B♭5 ( youtu.be/mkBPm8Ps6ME?t=115 ). Thoughts and opinions?

The highest I hear there is G5. Are there any plans to add more notes from live performances to this record?

[Hennessy Macklemore III]

The current owner of this thread is effectively an ex-user of the forum, so in order for the thread to get updated it will either require someone else to claim it and start a new thread, or for someone else to find a staff member willing to update the thread and send them the additional notes that need to be added to it. As long as it's not an overwhelming quantity of notes to add, I'd be willing to make some updates if you can tell me what needs to be added.

[Puffin]

Oh okay, I didn't have anything in particular in mind, I'd just listened to Live at Wembley recently and thought he had some good high notes that could be added.

[rob]

youtu.be/E5pUHHGoyBI?t=299

C6 here, that I believe is Roger. Pitching help courtesy of Electric Mami.

Would love to hear thoughts on it.

[Hennessy Macklemore III]

Sounds like a B5 to me, and are we sure it's not Freddie? The F♯5 underneath it sounds much more like Roger's signature high note vibrato to me.

[asgardvoxx]

Hello Mr. Macklemore III :)
Since RINGO is no longer actively updating this thread, I was just wondering if I could perhaps give you a suggestion since you seem open to implementing them (as of a 2 year old post, sure, but still worth a try).

I feel like the B4s are more bold-worthy than the E5 in “I’m in Love with My Car” — the note is solid, but it’s quite short and isn’t returned to time and time again like the masterfully powerful and highly consistent B4 notes that appear in the choruses and the verses. Based on that, I’d consider removing the bold formatting on the E5 and adding it to the B4 entry instead, although the E5 could still be linked since it is the highest note in the song and it might be worth knowing where it is.

Many thanks, asgardvoxx

[ellie]

Guy standing up in court painting: I think we shouldn’t be changing the bolds of other people’s threads even if they are functionally dead

[asgardvoxx]

I mean, I could get thread rights and launch a new Roger Taylor thread, but I am a busy man and it takes a lot of time and effort to maintain a (relatively) high-profile range thread such as this, which is something that still kind of scares me. Besides, it was just a suggestion, anyway.

[Hennessy Macklemore III]

Oct 18, 2024 19:25:10 GMT asgardvoxx said:

Hello Mr. Macklemore III :)
Since RINGO is no longer actively updating this thread, I was just wondering if I could perhaps give you a suggestion since you seem open to implementing them (as of a 2 year old post, sure, but still worth a try).

I feel like the B4s are more bold-worthy than the E5 in “I’m in Love with My Car” — the note is solid, but it’s quite short and isn’t returned to time and time again like the masterfully powerful and highly consistent B4 notes that appear in the choruses and the verses. Based on that, I’d consider removing the bold formatting on the E5 and adding it to the B4 entry instead, although the E5 could still be linked since it is the highest note in the song and it might be worth knowing where it is.

Many thanks, asgardvoxx

Hey there, just seeing this now. I'm kind of indifferent to this change in bolds myself, but I'd be willing to do it if other people are interested in seeing it implemented.