James Hetfield (61,935 views)

[senatorsenpai]

That's an interesting version. I do hear A1 around 3:59, not as resonant as his B1 but the pitch is clear. Around 6:41 I think I hear something in the sub B1 range when Henny Macc mentioned, but the lower frequencies are a bit muddled against the instrumental there, so I couldn't say an exact pitch with confidence.

[Electric Mami]

Vocals isolated: voca.ro/1l5uGInzMENi

So 3:51 actually touches C2 before dipping, not B1
3:54 is a B1 on the "death", 3:59 on the "me" C♯2 getting subby and touching B1 without subs by the end of the note
4:54 indeed C♯2
Still certain this is a C♯2 at 6:41 on the "me", and the "IMprisoning" is actually an E2. I can't tell what exactly I heard as G2 before getting C♯2. Some air? I don't know. Not that it matters anyway lol

[EddieCheivz]

[EddieCheivz]

-Listening to the isolation version Electric Mami provided I really just hear "Hold my breath as I wish for death, Oh please, God, wake me" as C#2s and B1s honestly, not A1s as I thought before.
-I also hear that "darkness imprisoning ME" certainly very far from "G1 or A1" as Henny said, I actually hear on them entire verse section as E2s.

So probably his range is still the same until this point guys IMO :( nothing really going below to B1 honestly

[Hennessy Macklemore III]

May 23, 2024 17:35:11 GMT Electric Mami said:

Vocals isolated: voca.ro/1l5uGInzMENi

So 3:51 actually touches C2 before dipping, not B1
3:54 is a B1 on the "death", 3:59 on the "me" C♯2 getting subby and touching B1 without subs by the end of the note
4:54 indeed C♯2
Still certain this is a C♯2 at 6:41 on the "me", and the "IMprisoning" is actually an E2. I can't tell what exactly I heard as G2 before getting C♯2. Some air? I don't know. Not that it matters anyway lol

Listening to this, I can agree with all the notes I heard as A1s being higher, though I think I hear the "me" at 3:59 getting down to B♭1ish still.

With that said, I'm only more convinced now that the note on "me" at 6:41 is in G1 territory. It is by far the lowest note in that line, and I have no idea how you guys are still hearing it as only E2-C♯2 range with the instruments gone.