Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 26, 2021 2:16:15 GMT
Harry Edward Nilsson III (June 15, 1941 - January 15, 1994) Vocal Range: C2 - G♯6Vocal Peak: 1970 - 1973; 1976 - 1979 {Vocal Summary} Harry Edward Nilsson III, professionally known as Nilsson, was an American singer-songwriter who reached the peak of his commercial success and popularity in the early 1970s. Nilsson was a tenor with a four octave vocal range, spanning from the bass low C (C2) up to the soprano high C (C6). Nilsson was born on June 15, 1941 and died on January 15, 1994 due to heart disease. He was 52 years old.
Written by @ianvector . Notewatched by @ianvector Edited by SailorBlue and Bes {Album Ranges}Solo:
Spotlight on Nilsson (1966): F♯2 - B4 - E♭5
Pandemonium Shadow Show (1967): G2 - G5
Aerial Ballet (1968): F2 - G4 - C5
Harry (1969): G2 - C♯5
Nilsson Sings Newman (1970): G2 - B4 - E5
The Point! (1970): B2 - G♯4 - A4
Aerial Pandemonium Ballet (1971): G♯2 - G5
Nilsson Schmilsson (1971): E2 - B4 - F5
Son of Schmilsson (1972): C2 - B4 - D5
A Little Touch of Schmilsson in the Night (1973): E2 - E4 - A4
Pussy Cats (1974): E2 - G5
Duit on Mon Dei (1975): F2 - F♯5
Sandman (1976): G♯2 - B4 - F5
...That's the Way It Is (1976): G♯2 - B4 - E5
Knnillssonn (1977): C2 - C6
Flash Harry (1980): D2 - G♯4 - E♭5
Losst and Founnd (2019): E2 - F4 - C♯5
Nilsson Sessions 1967 - 1968: B♭2 - E5
Nilsson Sessions 1968 - 1971:
Nilsson Sessions 1971 - 1974:
Nilsson Sessions 1967 - 1975:
Significant High Notes:
G♯6 ("Daylight", "I Never Thought I'd Get This Lonely")
C6 ("I Never Thought I'd Get This Lonely")
G5 ("River Deep, Mountain High", "Rock Around the Clock")
F♯5 ("It's a Jungle Out There", "Jump into the Fire")
F5 ("1941", "Good for God", "There Will Never Be")
E5 ("Cuddly Toy", "Coconut", "Let The Good Times Roll", "Many Rivers to Cross", "Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, "Rainmaker", "A Thousand Miles Away", "Vine Street")
E♭5 ("Cheek to Cheek", "How to Write a Song", "I'm Gonna Lose My Mind", "River Deep, Mountain High", "Sleep Late, My Lady Friend", "Subterranean Homesick Blues")
D5 ("Down", "Let The Good Times Roll", "The Moonbeam Song", "Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, "She's Just Laughing at Me", "Sixteen Tons", "Spaceman", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Vine Street", "What's Your Sign?", "Yellow Man", "You Can't Do That")
C♯5 ("Do You Believe", "Fairfax Rag", "I'm Gonna Lose My Mind", "Take 54", "Try")
C5 ("At My Front Door", "Bath", "Born in Grenada", "Coconut", "Cuddly Toy", "Daddy's Song", "Daylight", "Don't Leave Me", "Down", "Driving Along", "I'll Be Home", "Lost and Found", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "Mr. Tinker", "One", "Rain", "Rainmaker", "Searchin'")
B4 ("Ambush", "Do You Believe", "Early in the Morning", "Everybody's Talkin'", "The Family" 1967 Demo, "I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", "I'll Be Home", "It's a Jungle Out There", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Sandman Version, "Mother Nature's Son", "Mr. Bojangles", "Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "Sail Away", "Subterranean Homesick Blues", "Vine Street", "Without You")
B♭4 ("City Life", "How to Write a Song", "I Need You", "Leggenda", "The Puppy Song", "Remember (Christmas)", "River Deep, Mountain High", "Sail Away", "She's Leaving Home", "You're Breakin' My Heart")
A4 ("Blanket for a Sail", "Cowboy", "Don't Leave Me", "Down", "Everything's Got 'Em", "Fairfax Rag", "Freckles", "I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", "It's Been so Long", "Jump into the Fire", "Kojak Columbo", "Lean on Me", "Leggenda", "Let The Good Times Roll", "Living Without You", "Lost and Found", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Many Rivers to Cross", "The Moonbeam Song", "Mr. Tinker", "Old Dirt Road", "Open Your Window", "Poli High", "Sixteen Tons", "Subterranean Homesick Blues", "That Is All" Studio/Reprise, "This Is All I Ask", "Vine Street", "You Can't Take Your Love Away from Me", "You're Breakin' My Heart")
G♯4 ("City Life", "Daddy's Song" Aerial Pandemonium Ballet Version, "Down", "How to Write a Song", "It's a Jungle Out There", "Just One Look/Baby I'm Yours", "Lean on Me", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Rainmaker", "She's Just Laughing at Me", "Spaceman", "The Family" 1967 Demo, "Think About Your Troubles", "Without You")
G4 ("1941" 1967 Demo, "Ambush", "At My Front Door", "Best Move", "Cheek to Cheek", "Cowboy", "Daddy's Song" Aerial Pandemonium Ballet Version, "Don't Leave Me", "Early in the Morning", "The Family" 1967 Demo, "Good Times", "I Said Goodbye to Me", "I'll Never Leave You", "It's Been so Long", "Leggenda", "Let The Good Times Roll", "Living Without You", "Lost and Found", "Many Rivers to Cross", "Nevertheless (I'm In Love With You)", "Old Dirt Road", "One" Aerial Ballet Version, "Open Your Window", "Poli High", "The Puppy Song", "Remember (Christmas)", "She's Leaving Home", "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear", "Sweet Surrender", "Ten Little Indians", "That Is All" Studio/Reprise, "The Wailing of the Willow", "A Thousand Miles Away", "There Will Never Be", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Turn Out the Light", "You Made Me Love You")
F♯4 ("1941", "Black Sails", "Daddy's Song" Aerial Ballet Version, "Do You Believe", "Early in the Morning", "Fairfax Rag", "I'd Rather Be Dead", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Sandman Version, "Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "One" 1968 Demo, "Searchin'" 1967 Demo, "She Wandered Through the Garden Fence", "Sister Marie" Stereo Remix, "So Long Dad", "So You Think You've Got Troubles", "Take 54", "There Will Never Be", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Will She Miss Me", "Zombie Jamboree (Back to Back)")
F4 ("Black Sails", "Blanket for a Sail", "Caroline", "Don't Forget Me", "Driving Along", "Good for God", "Gotta Get Up", "I Need You", "I'll Take a Tango", "It's a Jungle Out There", "I've Got It!", "Just One Look/Baby I'm Yours", "Leggenda", "Listen, The Snow Is Falling", "Living Without You", "Loop de Loop", "Many Rivers to Cross", "Maybe", "Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, "Open Your Window", "The Path That Leads to Trouble", "Perfect Day", "Poli High", "The Puppy Song", "Rainmaker", "Sail Away", "Salmon Falls", "Save the Last Dance for Me", "She Sang Hymns Out of Tune", "She's Just Laughing at Me", "Spaceman", "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Together", "U.C.L.A.", "What Does a Woman See in a Man", "What's Your Sign?", "Who Done It?", "Will She Miss Me", "Without Her", "Yellow Man", "You Can't Do That")
Significant Low Notes:
E3 ("Always", "Best Move", "Daylight", "Don’t Leave Me", "Early in the Morning", "Everything’s Got ‘Em", "Goin' Down", "Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", "I've Got It!", "Kojak Columbo", "Lazy Moon", "Lullabye", "Nevertheless (I’m In Love With You)", "Me and My Arrow", "Miss Butter’s Lament", "Moonshine Bandit", "Mr. Richland’s Favorite Song", "Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "Rain", "Salmon Falls", "Sleep Late My Lady Friend", "Something True", "Sweet Surrender", "A Thousand Miles Away", "Together" Alternate Version, "What’ll I Do", "You Can’t Take Your Love Away From Me", "You Made Me Love You")
E♭3 ("Listen, The Snow Is Falling", "Me and My Arrow", "The Puppy Song", "She’s Leaving Home", "Sweet Surrender")
D3 ("Animal Farm", "Black Sails", "Driving Along", "Everybody’s Talkin’", "Growin’ Up", "I Wonder Who’s Kissing Her Now", "I’d Rather Be Dead", "Lost and Found", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Makin’ Whoopee!", "Miss Butter’s Lament", "Mr. Bojangles", "Mucho Mungo/Mt. Elga", "Old Forgotten Soldier", "The Ivy Covered Walls", "The Moonbeam Song", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "River Deep, Mountain High", "She Sits Down on Me", "Think About Your Troubles", "Turn on Your Radio", "What’ll I Do", "Without Her", "You Can’t Do That")
C♯3 ("As I Wander Lonely" 1967 Demo, "Cowboy", "Cuddly Toy" 1967 Demo, "How Long Can Disco On", "I’m Gonna Lose My Mind", "It's So Easy", "I've Got It!", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Duit on Mon Dei Version, "Many Rivers to Cross", "Moonshine Bandit", "One" 1968 Demo, "Open Your Window", "Pretty Soon There'll Be Nothing Left for Everybody", "There Will Never Be", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today", "What’ll I Do", "Without You", "Yellow Man", "You Made Me Love You")
C3 ("Ambush", "As Time Goes By", "At My Front Door", "Black Sails", "Cheek to Cheek", "Dayton Ohio 1903", "Down by the Sea", "Driving Along", "Easier for Me", "For Me and My Gal", "Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", "I Said Goodbye to Me", "I Wonder Who's Kissing Her Now", "I'll Take a Tango", "Lazy Moon", "Living Without You", "Rain", "Rock Around the Clock", "She Sits Down on Me", "Signs" 1967 Demo, "There Will Never Be", "What Does a Woman See in a Man", "Woman Oh Woman", "You Made Me Love You")
B2 ("All I Think About Is You", "Are You Sleeping?", "As I Wander Lonely", "As Time Goes By", "Black Sails", "Cheek to Cheek", "Daylight", "Down by the Sea", "For Me and My Gal", "I Said Goodbye to Me" Alternate Version, "I'll Take a Tango", "It Had to Be You", "Lazy Moon", "Lost and Found", "Love Is the Answer", "Lullabye", "Moonshine Bandit", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "One", "Puget Sound", "Remember (Christmas)", "Sixteen Tons", "Something True", "Think About Your Troubles", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today", "Turn Out the Light", "Who Done It?", "Will She Miss Me", "Woman Oh Woman", "You Can't Do That")
B♭2 ("Coconut", "How Long Can Disco On", "I Don't Need You", "I Said Goodbye to Me" Alternate Version, "It Had to Be You", "Lean on Me", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Makin' Whoopee!", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "One" 1968 Demo, "There Will Never Be", "U.C.L.A.")
A2 ("I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", "It's a Jungle Out There", "Mucho Mungo/Mt. Elga", "One", "Who Done It?", "Without Her")
G♯2 ("All My Life", "Good Old Desk", "Sail Away", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today")
G2 ("All I Think About Is You", "Always", "At My Front Door", "Daddy's Song", "Growin' Up", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "Mournin' Glory Story", "Old Bones", "Puget Sound", "The Lottery Song", "This Is All I Ask", "The Wailing of the Willow", "Who Done It?", "Without Her")
F♯2 ("Growin' Up", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "Makin' Whoopee!")
F2 ("Home", "Laughin' Man", "Save the Last Dance for Me", "U.C.L.A.", "The Wailing of the Willow", "What's Your Sign?", "You Made Me Love You")
E2 ("Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", "I Never Thought I'd Get This Lonely", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "The Moonbeam Song", "Old Forgotten Soldier")
E♭2 ("I Don't Need You", "Old Bones")
D2 ("Home" rough mix)
C♯2 ("I Think I'm Getting Old")
C2 ("Take 54", "Who Done It?")
{Questionable Notes}
D7 ("I'll Take a Tango" Quad mix [5])
A6 ("Daylight" [1])
C6 ("Old Forgotten Soldier" [1])
B5 ("Loop de Loop" [1])
G♯5 ("Zombie Jamboree (Back to Back)" [1])
G5 ("Searchin'" [1])
F♯5 ("How to Write a Song" [3])
A4 ("(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today" [1], "Will She Miss Me" [1])
F♯4 ("The Flying Saucer Song" [5])
F4 ("Laughin' Man" [3])
C3 ("Life Line" [3])
G♯2 ("Yellow Man" [3])
G2 ("Spaceman" [4])
F♯2 ("I Said Goodbye to Me" [3])
E♭2 ("The Flying Saucer Song" [5])
D2 ("Bright Side of Life" [3], "She Sits Down on Me" [1])
C2 ("Joy" [3], "U.C.L.A." [5], "What's Your Sign?" [1], "Zombie Jamboree" [4])
C♯2 - E♭3 (Various narration tracks from "The Point!" [5])
.......................................................
[1] marks yelps and short trills in high range or anacrusis and short dips in low range.
[2] marks notes of questionable identity that cannot be confirmed to be the singer in question.
[3] marks non-melodic notes that don't have a significant enough pitch to warrant inclusion.
[4] marks notes that possess uncertain pitch or have been pitch-shifted.
[5] marks notes that do not fit the previous criteria but are not of a substantial enough quality to warrant counting towards the singer's range.
.......................................................
Blue marks falsetto or whistle notes.
Green marks harsh and distorted notes.
Underlines mark notes that are obscured in the song mix.
Italics mark non-melodic notes.
Boldface mark notes that are considered to be particularly notable examples of this person's vocal capabilities. |
|
|
|
Post by SailorBlue on Nov 26, 2021 2:35:11 GMT
1: I think you would benefit by using this template. 2: The "Daylight" G6 gets up to A6 and I personally wouldn't count it (edit: I saw you linked a better G6 that I didn't initially see, I was referring to the one at the end of the song, but I still wouldn't count the G6 either, despite it being slightly better.). The C6 is shockingly enough, completely fine. Hell, I'd call it melodic and black. Not what I expected from this guy. 3: I'd personally remove everything below G4 in the highs section. D4 maybe depending on how low his voice is. |
|
Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 26, 2021 2:36:53 GMT
1: I think you would benefit by using this template. 2: The "Daylight" G6 gets up to A6 and I personally wouldn't count it. The C6 is shockingly enough, completely fine. Hell, I'd call it melodic and black. Not what I expected from this guy. 3: I'd personally remove everything below G4 in the highs section. D4 maybe depending on how low his voice is. Thanks for the feedback. This is my first time making a thread. |
|
|
|
Post by SailorBlue on Nov 26, 2021 2:38:42 GMT
1: I think you would benefit by using this template. 2: The "Daylight" G6 gets up to A6 and I personally wouldn't count it. The C6 is shockingly enough, completely fine. Hell, I'd call it melodic and black. Not what I expected from this guy. 3: I'd personally remove everything below G4 in the highs section. D4 maybe depending on how low his voice is. Thanks for the feedback. This is my first time making a thread. Don't worry, we all start from somewhere. God forbid if anyone remembers my first thread. |
|
|
|
Post by rob on Nov 26, 2021 5:13:17 GMT
Personally I think the G6 is decently countable. It sounds rather strained definitely, but to me at least, the note is still clear.
|
|
Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 26, 2021 5:24:12 GMT
Personally I think the G6 is decently countable. It sounds rather strained definitely, but to me at least, the note is still clear. I was actually on the fence about including this one, but I think I’ll keep it on here. |
|
|
|
Post by rob on Nov 26, 2021 6:23:40 GMT
Personally I think the G6 is decently countable. It sounds rather strained definitely, but to me at least, the note is still clear. I was actually on the fence about including this one, but I think I’ll keep it on here. It's your thread man, you should have every right to include a note if you feel it's strong enough, within reason of course lol. Harry Nilsson is actually a singer I had listened to a sparse bit here and there, but seeing how wide his range is makes me want to dive more into his work. |
|
|
|
|
|
Post by clem on Nov 26, 2021 11:08:32 GMT
The G6 itself isn't the worst note, but it leaves such range gap that I wouldn't include it.
|
|
Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 26, 2021 16:48:58 GMT
The G6 itself isn't the worst note, but it leaves such range gap that I wouldn't include it. I think Willie Nelson's thread has a much wider gap. The two highest notes on Nelson's thread are A4 and Eb5. |
|
Karen’s Kickassarole
Vocal Novice
Offline
TheRealRomanHeath’s Mobile Alt
Posts: 96
Likes: 218
Join Date: May 2020
|
Post by Karen’s Kickassarole on Nov 26, 2021 19:44:23 GMT
I’ve never wanted to be a questionable D2 more 😭
|
|
Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 26, 2021 20:44:30 GMT
I’ve never wanted to be a questionable D2 more 😭 😂😂😂 I’ve never wanted to be a questionable D2 more 😭 If that's true, you may want to take a look at the Eb2. (Yes, it's a real song). www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5onD2WqBWEI'm currently in the process of completely remaking the thread. I'm currently going through all of his albums again and I expect the thread to be finalized soon. |
|
|
|
Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 28, 2021 22:51:00 GMT
Um, I'm not sure why I've only just noticed this, but based on our DMs I didn't give you exclusive permission to post this when it's still under my name in claims  Oh yeah, sorry. I meant to ask you about that a while ago. You hadn't responded to my messages for about a month, so I decided to go ahead and do it. I hope that's alright. If not, you can take this thread if you want it and I'll move onto some of my other in-progress threads. I'm actually working on completely re-making the entire thread, since I don't think I did a very good job with this initially. I will completely re-make the thread with my new research and I'll probably be finished notewatching all of Nilsson's stuff in about a week, so that's when I'll be finished updating the thread. Sorry for any confusion this may have caused. :) - Ian |
|
|
|
Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 29, 2021 0:57:30 GMT
Apologies for not responding for so long, I just got busy with life and that. For future reference, though, I did message you after a while and you responded, but you hadn't given any indication you'd actually posted the thread which was kind of what irked me here. I'll leave the thread with you for now but I'll post a few things in the thread when I have a moment as to how to improve the thread if that's alright (nothing major, just a few things). Thanks for understanding! And once again, sorry for the confusion. I meant to tell you about the thread earlier. |
|
Deleted
Offline
Posts: 0
Join Date: January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 3, 2022 22:24:40 GMT
I still have to add Losst and Founnd and a few other things, but besides that, it's pretty much complete. (And of course I'll keep adding to it as I find more Nilsson stuff to notewatch, but I definitely got the bulk of it done).
Edit: It's complete. I finally did it. Maybe I'll work on Al Jolson or Frank Sinatra Jr. next...
|
|
|
|
Post by Macca on Jan 5, 2022 2:12:46 GMT
it sounds like E2 in the B1 clip and i think the song is transposed up by 1 so it would be F2 and it sounds like a B1 but its very brief and pretty much shouldnt be counted
|
|
|
|
Post by SailorBlue on Jan 5, 2022 8:34:32 GMT
Alright, so it's about time some things are addressed. I'll make this quick. Dogshit extremities. Too many bolds. Pitching Errors. Redundant labeling. Alphabetization issues. As well as other misc. issues. The good news is that me and one of my compadres cleaned the thing up. So you can just copy & paste it. (Just be sure to not accidentally include the spoiler that encases the thread). This took me hours so I really hope you use this. {Cleaned up thread.} Harry Edward Nilsson III (June 15, 1941 - January 15, 1994) Vocal Range: C2 - C6{Album Ranges}Solo:
Spotlight on Nilsson (1966): F♯2 - B4 - E♭5
Pandemonium Shadow Show (1967): G2 - G5
Aerial Ballet (1968): F2 - G4 - C5
Harry (1969): G2 - C♯5
Nilsson Sings Newman (1970): G2 - B4 - E5
The Point! (1970): B2 - G♯4 - A4
Aerial Pandemonium Ballet (1971): G♯2 - G5
Nilsson Schmilsson (1971): E2 - B4 - F5
Son of Schmilsson (1972): C2 - B4 - D5
A Little Touch of Schmilsson in the Night (1973): E2 - E4 - A4
Pussy Cats (1974): E2 - G5
Duit on Mon Dei (1975): F2 - F♯5
Sandman (1976): G♯2 - B4 - F5
...That's the Way It Is (1976): G♯2 - B4 - C5
Knnillssonn (1977): C2 - C6
Flash Harry (1980): D2 - G♯4 - E♭5
Losst and Founnd (2019): E2 - F4 - C♯5
Nilsson Sessions 1967 - 1968: B♭2 - E5
Nilsson Sessions 1968 - 1971:
Nilsson Sessions 1971 - 1974:
Nilsson Sessions 1967 - 1975:
Significant High Notes: C6 ("I Never Thought I'd Get This Lonely") G5 (" River Deep, Mountain High", "Rock Around the Clock") F♯5 (" It's a Jungle Out There", " Jump into the Fire") F5 (" 1941", " Good for God", " There Will Never Be") E5 (" Cuddly Toy", " Coconut", " Let The Good Times Roll", " Many Rivers to Cross", " Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, " Rainmaker", " A Thousand Miles Away", "Vine Street") E♭5 (" Cheek to Cheek", " How to Write a Song", " I'm Gonna Lose My Mind", " River Deep, Mountain High", " Sleep Late, My Lady Friend", "Subterranean Homesick Blues") D5 (" Down", " Let The Good Times Roll", " The Moonbeam Song", " Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, " She's Just Laughing at Me", " Sixteen Tons", " Spaceman", " This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, " Vine Street", "What's Your Sign?", " Yellow Man", " You Can't Do That") C♯5 (" Do You Believe", "Fairfax Rag", " I'm Gonna Lose My Mind", " Take 54", " Try") C5 (" At My Front Door", " Bath", " Born in Grenada", " Coconut", " Cuddly Toy", "Daddy's Song", " Daylight", " Don't Leave Me", "Down", " Driving Along", " I'll Be Home", " Lost and Found", " The Most Beautiful World in the World", " Mr. Tinker", " One", " Rainmaker", " Searchin'") B4 ("Ambush", "Do You Believe", " Early in the Morning", " Everybody's Talkin'", "The Family" 1967 Demo, " I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", " I'll Be Home", " It's a Jungle Out There", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Sandman Version, " Mother Nature's Son", " Mr. Bojangles", " Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "Sail Away", "Subterranean Homesick Blues", " Vine Street", " Without You") B♭4 (" City Life", "How to Write a Song", "I Need You", " Leggenda", " The Puppy Song", " Remember (Christmas)", " River Deep, Mountain High", "Sail Away", " She's Leaving Home", "You're Breakin' My Heart") A4 ("Blanket for a Sail", "Cowboy", " Don't Leave Me", " Down", " Everything's Got 'Em", "Fairfax Rag", " Freckles", " I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", " It's Been so Long", " Jump into the Fire", "Kojak Columbo", " Lean on Me", " Leggenda", "Let The Good Times Roll", "Living Without You", " Lost and Found", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Many Rivers to Cross", " The Moonbeam Song", " Mr. Tinker", " Old Dirt Road", " Open Your Window", " Poli High", " Sixteen Tons", "Subterranean Homesick Blues", " That Is All" Studio/Reprise, " This Is All I Ask", "Vine Street", " You Can't Take Your Love Away from Me", "You're Breakin' My Heart") G♯4 (" City Life", " Daddy's Song" Aerial Pandemonium Ballet Version, "Down", "How to Write a Song", "It's a Jungle Out There", "Just One Look/Baby I'm Yours", " Lean on Me", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Rainmaker", " She's Just Laughing at Me", "Spaceman", " The Family" 1967 Demo, "Think About Your Troubles", " Without You") G4 ("1941" 1967 Demo, " Ambush", "At My Front Door", " Best Move", " Cheek to Cheek", "Cowboy", " Daddy's Song" Aerial Pandemonium Ballet Version, "Don't Leave Me", "Early in the Morning", "The Family" 1967 Demo, " Good Times", " I Said Goodbye to Me", " I'll Never Leave You", " It's Been so Long", "Leggenda", "Let The Good Times Roll", " Living Without You", "Lost and Found", "Many Rivers to Cross", " Nevertheless (I'm In Love With You)", "Old Dirt Road", " One" Aerial Ballet Version, " Open Your Window", " Poli High", "The Puppy Song", " Remember (Christmas)", " She's Leaving Home", "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear", " Sweet Surrender", "Ten Little Indians", " That Is All" Studio/Reprise, "A Thousand Miles Away", "There Will Never Be", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Turn Out the Light", " You Made Me Love You") F♯4 ("1941", "Black Sails", "Daddy's Song" Aerial Ballet Version, "Do You Believe", " Early in the Morning", "Fairfax Rag", " I'd Rather Be Dead", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Sandman Version, "Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "One" 1968 Demo, "Searchin'" 1967 Demo, "She Wandered Through the Garden Fence", " Sister Marie" Stereo Remix, "So Long Dad", "So You Think You've Got Troubles", "Take 54", "There Will Never Be", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Will She Miss Me", "Zombie Jamboree (Back to Back)") F4 ("Black Sails", " Blanket for a Sail", "Caroline", "Don't Forget Me", "Driving Along", "Good for God", "Gotta Get Up", "I Need You", " I'll Take a Tango", "It's a Jungle Out There", "I've Got It!", "Just One Look/Baby I'm Yours", "Leggenda", "Listen, The Snow Is Falling", "Living Without You", "Loop de Loop", "Many Rivers to Cross", " Maybe", "Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, "Open Your Window", "The Path That Leads to Trouble", "Perfect Day", "Poli High", "The Puppy Song", "Rainmaker", "Sail Away", "Salmon Falls", "Save the Last Dance for Me", "She Sang Hymns Out of Tune", " She's Just Laughing at Me", "Spaceman", "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Together", " U.C.L.A.", "What Does a Woman See in a Man", "What's Your Sign?", "Who Done It?", "Will She Miss Me", " Without Her", "Yellow Man", "You Can't Do That") Significant Low Notes: E3 ("Always", "Best Move", "Daylight", "Don’t Leave Me", "Early in the Morning", "Everything’s Got ‘Em", "Goin' Down", "Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", "I've Got It!", "Kojak Columbo", "Lazy Moon", "Lullabye", "Nevertheless (I’m In Love With You)", "Me and My Arrow", "Miss Butter’s Lament", "Moonshine Bandit", "Mr. Richland’s Favorite Song", "Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "Rain", "Salmon Falls", "Sleep Late My Lady Friend", "Something True", "Sweet Surrender", "A Thousand Miles Away", "Together" Alternate Version, "What’ll I Do", "You Can’t Take Your Love Away From Me", "You Made Me Love You") E♭3 ("Listen, The Snow Is Falling", "Me and My Arrow", "The Puppy Song", "She’s Leaving Home", "Sweet Surrender") D3 ("Animal Farm", "Black Sails", "Driving Along", "Everybody’s Talkin’", "Growin’ Up", "I Wonder Who’s Kissing Her Now", "I’d Rather Be Dead", "Lost and Found", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Makin’ Whoopee!", "Miss Butter’s Lament", "Mr. Bojangles", "Mucho Mungo/Mt. Elga", "Old Forgotten Soldier", "The Ivy Covered Walls", "The Moonbeam Song", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "River Deep, Mountain High", "She Sits Down on Me", "Think About Your Troubles", "Turn on Your Radio", "What’ll I Do", "Without Her", "You Can’t Do That") C♯3 ("As I Wander Lonely" 1967 Demo, "Cowboy", "Cuddly Toy" 1967 Demo, "How Long Can Disco On", "I’m Gonna Lose My Mind", "It's So Easy", "I've Got It!", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Duit on Mon Dei Version, "Many Rivers to Cross", "Moonshine Bandit", "One" 1968 Demo, "Open Your Window", "Pretty Soon There'll Be Nothing Left for Everybody", "There Will Never Be", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today", "What’ll I Do", "Without You", "Yellow Man", "You Made Me Love You") C3 ("Ambush", "As Time Goes By", " At My Front Door", "Black Sails", "Cheek to Cheek", "Dayton Ohio 1903", "Down by the Sea", "Driving Along", "Easier for Me", "For Me and My Gal", "Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", " I Said Goodbye to Me", "I Wonder Who's Kissing Her Now", "I'll Take a Tango", "Lazy Moon", "Living Without You", "Rain", "Rock Around the Clock", "She Sits Down on Me", "Signs" 1967 Demo, " There Will Never Be", "What Does a Woman See in a Man", "Woman Oh Woman", "You Made Me Love You") B2 ("All I Think About Is You", "Are You Sleeping?", "As I Wander Lonely", "As Time Goes By", "Black Sails", "Cheek to Cheek", "Daylight", "Down by the Sea", "For Me and My Gal", "I Said Goodbye to Me" Alternate Version, "I'll Take a Tango", "It Had to Be You", "Lazy Moon", "Lost and Found", "Love Is the Answer", "Lullabye", "Moonshine Bandit", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "One", "Puget Sound", "Remember (Christmas)", "Sixteen Tons", "Something True", "Think About Your Troubles", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today", "Turn Out the Light", "Who Done It?", "Will She Miss Me", "Woman Oh Woman", "You Can't Do That") B♭2 ("Coconut", "How Long Can Disco On", "I Don't Need You", "I Said Goodbye to Me" Alternate Version, "It Had to Be You", "Lean on Me", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Makin' Whoopee!", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "One" 1968 Demo, "There Will Never Be", "U.C.L.A.") A2 ("I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", "It's a Jungle Out There", "Mucho Mungo/Mt. Elga", "One", "Who Done It?", " Without Her") G♯2 ("All My Life", "Good Old Desk", "Sail Away", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today") G2 ("All I Think About Is You", "Always", "At My Front Door", "Daddy's Song", "Growin' Up", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "Mournin' Glory Story", "Old Bones", "Puget Sound", " The Lottery Song", " This Is All I Ask", " The Wailing of the Willow", "Who Done It?", "Without Her") F♯2 ("Growin' Up", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "Makin' Whoopee!") F2 ("Home", "Laughin' Man", " Save the Last Dance for Me", "U.C.L.A.", "The Wailing of the Willow", "What's Your Sign?", "You Made Me Love You") E2 (" Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", "I Never Thought I'd Get This Lonely", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "The Moonbeam Song", " Old Forgotten Soldier") E♭2 ("I Don't Need You", " Old Bones") C♯2 (" I Think I'm Getting Old") C2 ("Take 54", " Who Done It?") {Questionable Notes}A6 ("Daylight" [1])
G♯6 ("Daylight" [5])
C6 ("Old Forgotten Soldier" [1])
B5 ("Loop de Loop" [1])
G♯5 ("Zombie Jamboree (Back to Back)" [1])
G5 ("Searchin'" [1])
F♯5 ("How to Write a Song" [3])
A4 ("(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today" [1], "Will She Miss Me" [1])
F♯4 ("The Flying Saucer Song" [5])
F4 ("Laughin' Man" [3])
C3 ("Life Line" [3])
G♯2 ("Yellow Man" [3])
G2 ("Spaceman" [4])
F♯2 ("I Said Goodbye to Me" [3])
E♭2 ("The Flying Saucer Song" [5])
D2 ("Bright Side of Life" [3], "She Sits Down on Me" [1])
C2 ("Joy" [3], "U.C.L.A." [5], "What's Your Sign?" [1], "Zombie Jamboree" [4])
C♯2 - E♭3 (Various narration tracks from "The Point!" [5])
.......................................................
[1] marks yelps and short trills in high range or anacrusis and short dips in low range.
[2] marks notes of questionable identity that cannot be confirmed to be the singer in question.
[3] marks non-melodic notes that don't have a significant enough pitch to warrant inclusion.
[4] marks notes that possess uncertain pitch or have been pitch-shifted.
[5] marks notes that do not fit the previous criteria but are not of a substantial enough quality to warrant counting towards the singer's range. .......................................................
Blue marks falsetto or whistle notes.
Green marks harsh and distorted notes.
Underlines mark notes that are obscured in the song mix.
Italics mark non-melodic notes.
Boldface marks notes that are considered to be particularly notable examples of this person's vocal capabilities. |
|
|
|
Post by Macca on Jan 5, 2022 13:16:52 GMT
Roman I know it's a messy thread but it's the man's first thread if your just Gonna hate on someone's first thread at least make some good comments about it
|
|
|
|
Post by rob on Jan 5, 2022 17:11:31 GMT
Alright, so it's about time some things are addressed. I'll make this quick. Dogshit extremities. Too many bolds. Pitching Errors. Redundant labeling. Alphabetization issues. As well as other misc. issues. The good news is that me and one of my compadres cleaned the thing up. So you can just copy & paste it. (Just be sure to not accidentally include the spoiler that encases the thread). This took me hours so I really hope you use this. {Cleaned up thread.} Harry Edward Nilsson III (June 15, 1941 - January 15, 1994) Vocal Range: C2 - C6{Album Ranges}Solo:
Spotlight on Nilsson (1966): F♯2 - B4 - E♭5
Pandemonium Shadow Show (1967): G2 - G5
Aerial Ballet (1968): F2 - G4 - C5
Harry (1969): G2 - C♯5
Nilsson Sings Newman (1970): G2 - B4 - E5
The Point! (1970): B2 - G♯4 - A4
Aerial Pandemonium Ballet (1971): G♯2 - G5
Nilsson Schmilsson (1971): E2 - B4 - F5
Son of Schmilsson (1972): C2 - B4 - D5
A Little Touch of Schmilsson in the Night (1973): E2 - E4 - A4
Pussy Cats (1974): E2 - G5
Duit on Mon Dei (1975): F2 - F♯5
Sandman (1976): G♯2 - B4 - F5
...That's the Way It Is (1976): G♯2 - B4 - C5
Knnillssonn (1977): C2 - C6
Flash Harry (1980): D2 - G♯4 - E♭5
Losst and Founnd (2019): E2 - F4 - C♯5
Nilsson Sessions 1967 - 1968: B♭2 - E5
Nilsson Sessions 1968 - 1971:
Nilsson Sessions 1971 - 1974:
Nilsson Sessions 1967 - 1975:
Significant High Notes: C6 ("I Never Thought I'd Get This Lonely") G5 (" River Deep, Mountain High", "Rock Around the Clock") F♯5 (" It's a Jungle Out There", " Jump into the Fire") F5 (" 1941", " Good for God", " There Will Never Be") E5 (" Cuddly Toy", " Coconut", " Let The Good Times Roll", " Many Rivers to Cross", " Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, " Rainmaker", " A Thousand Miles Away", "Vine Street") E♭5 (" Cheek to Cheek", " How to Write a Song", " I'm Gonna Lose My Mind", " River Deep, Mountain High", " Sleep Late, My Lady Friend", "Subterranean Homesick Blues") D5 (" Down", " Let The Good Times Roll", " The Moonbeam Song", " Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, " She's Just Laughing at Me", " Sixteen Tons", " Spaceman", " This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, " Vine Street", "What's Your Sign?", " Yellow Man", " You Can't Do That") C♯5 (" Do You Believe", "Fairfax Rag", " I'm Gonna Lose My Mind", " Take 54", " Try") C5 (" At My Front Door", " Bath", " Born in Grenada", " Coconut", " Cuddly Toy", "Daddy's Song", " Daylight", " Don't Leave Me", "Down", " Driving Along", " I'll Be Home", " Lost and Found", " The Most Beautiful World in the World", " Mr. Tinker", " One", " Rainmaker", " Searchin'") B4 ("Ambush", "Do You Believe", " Early in the Morning", " Everybody's Talkin'", "The Family" 1967 Demo, " I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", " I'll Be Home", " It's a Jungle Out There", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Sandman Version, " Mother Nature's Son", " Mr. Bojangles", " Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "Sail Away", "Subterranean Homesick Blues", " Vine Street", " Without You") B♭4 (" City Life", "How to Write a Song", "I Need You", " Leggenda", " The Puppy Song", " Remember (Christmas)", " River Deep, Mountain High", "Sail Away", " She's Leaving Home", "You're Breakin' My Heart") A4 ("Blanket for a Sail", "Cowboy", " Don't Leave Me", " Down", " Everything's Got 'Em", "Fairfax Rag", " Freckles", " I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", " It's Been so Long", " Jump into the Fire", "Kojak Columbo", " Lean on Me", " Leggenda", "Let The Good Times Roll", "Living Without You", " Lost and Found", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Many Rivers to Cross", " The Moonbeam Song", " Mr. Tinker", " Old Dirt Road", " Open Your Window", " Poli High", " Sixteen Tons", "Subterranean Homesick Blues", " That Is All" Studio/Reprise, " This Is All I Ask", "Vine Street", " You Can't Take Your Love Away from Me", "You're Breakin' My Heart") G♯4 (" City Life", " Daddy's Song" Aerial Pandemonium Ballet Version, "Down", "How to Write a Song", "It's a Jungle Out There", "Just One Look/Baby I'm Yours", " Lean on Me", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Rainmaker", " She's Just Laughing at Me", "Spaceman", " The Family" 1967 Demo, "Think About Your Troubles", " Without You") G4 ("1941" 1967 Demo, " Ambush", "At My Front Door", " Best Move", " Cheek to Cheek", "Cowboy", " Daddy's Song" Aerial Pandemonium Ballet Version, "Don't Leave Me", "Early in the Morning", "The Family" 1967 Demo, " Good Times", " I Said Goodbye to Me", " I'll Never Leave You", " It's Been so Long", "Leggenda", "Let The Good Times Roll", " Living Without You", "Lost and Found", "Many Rivers to Cross", " Nevertheless (I'm In Love With You)", "Old Dirt Road", " One" Aerial Ballet Version, " Open Your Window", " Poli High", "The Puppy Song", " Remember (Christmas)", " She's Leaving Home", "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear", " Sweet Surrender", "Ten Little Indians", " That Is All" Studio/Reprise, "A Thousand Miles Away", "There Will Never Be", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Turn Out the Light", " You Made Me Love You") F♯4 ("1941", "Black Sails", "Daddy's Song" Aerial Ballet Version, "Do You Believe", " Early in the Morning", "Fairfax Rag", " I'd Rather Be Dead", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Sandman Version, "Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "One" 1968 Demo, "Searchin'" 1967 Demo, "She Wandered Through the Garden Fence", " Sister Marie" Stereo Remix, "So Long Dad", "So You Think You've Got Troubles", "Take 54", "There Will Never Be", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Will She Miss Me", "Zombie Jamboree (Back to Back)") F4 ("Black Sails", " Blanket for a Sail", "Caroline", "Don't Forget Me", "Driving Along", "Good for God", "Gotta Get Up", "I Need You", " I'll Take a Tango", "It's a Jungle Out There", "I've Got It!", "Just One Look/Baby I'm Yours", "Leggenda", "Listen, The Snow Is Falling", "Living Without You", "Loop de Loop", "Many Rivers to Cross", " Maybe", "Mr. Tinker" Alternate Version, "Open Your Window", "The Path That Leads to Trouble", "Perfect Day", "Poli High", "The Puppy Song", "Rainmaker", "Sail Away", "Salmon Falls", "Save the Last Dance for Me", "She Sang Hymns Out of Tune", " She's Just Laughing at Me", "Spaceman", "Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear", "This Could Be the Night" 1967 Demo, "Together", " U.C.L.A.", "What Does a Woman See in a Man", "What's Your Sign?", "Who Done It?", "Will She Miss Me", " Without Her", "Yellow Man", "You Can't Do That") Significant Low Notes: E3 ("Always", "Best Move", "Daylight", "Don’t Leave Me", "Early in the Morning", "Everything’s Got ‘Em", "Goin' Down", "Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", "I've Got It!", "Kojak Columbo", "Lazy Moon", "Lullabye", "Nevertheless (I’m In Love With You)", "Me and My Arrow", "Miss Butter’s Lament", "Moonshine Bandit", "Mr. Richland’s Favorite Song", "Nobody Cares About the Railroads Anymore", "Rain", "Salmon Falls", "Sleep Late My Lady Friend", "Something True", "Sweet Surrender", "A Thousand Miles Away", "Together" Alternate Version, "What’ll I Do", "You Can’t Take Your Love Away From Me", "You Made Me Love You") E♭3 ("Listen, The Snow Is Falling", "Me and My Arrow", "The Puppy Song", "She’s Leaving Home", "Sweet Surrender") D3 ("Animal Farm", "Black Sails", "Driving Along", "Everybody’s Talkin’", "Growin’ Up", "I Wonder Who’s Kissing Her Now", "I’d Rather Be Dead", "Lost and Found", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Makin’ Whoopee!", "Miss Butter’s Lament", "Mr. Bojangles", "Mucho Mungo/Mt. Elga", "Old Forgotten Soldier", "The Ivy Covered Walls", "The Moonbeam Song", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "River Deep, Mountain High", "She Sits Down on Me", "Think About Your Troubles", "Turn on Your Radio", "What’ll I Do", "Without Her", "You Can’t Do That") C♯3 ("As I Wander Lonely" 1967 Demo, "Cowboy", "Cuddly Toy" 1967 Demo, "How Long Can Disco On", "I’m Gonna Lose My Mind", "It's So Easy", "I've Got It!", "Jesus Christ You're Tall" Duit on Mon Dei Version, "Many Rivers to Cross", "Moonshine Bandit", "One" 1968 Demo, "Open Your Window", "Pretty Soon There'll Be Nothing Left for Everybody", "There Will Never Be", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today", "What’ll I Do", "Without You", "Yellow Man", "You Made Me Love You") C3 ("Ambush", "As Time Goes By", " At My Front Door", "Black Sails", "Cheek to Cheek", "Dayton Ohio 1903", "Down by the Sea", "Driving Along", "Easier for Me", "For Me and My Gal", "Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", " I Said Goodbye to Me", "I Wonder Who's Kissing Her Now", "I'll Take a Tango", "Lazy Moon", "Living Without You", "Rain", "Rock Around the Clock", "She Sits Down on Me", "Signs" 1967 Demo, " There Will Never Be", "What Does a Woman See in a Man", "Woman Oh Woman", "You Made Me Love You") B2 ("All I Think About Is You", "Are You Sleeping?", "As I Wander Lonely", "As Time Goes By", "Black Sails", "Cheek to Cheek", "Daylight", "Down by the Sea", "For Me and My Gal", "I Said Goodbye to Me" Alternate Version, "I'll Take a Tango", "It Had to Be You", "Lazy Moon", "Lost and Found", "Love Is the Answer", "Lullabye", "Moonshine Bandit", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "One", "Puget Sound", "Remember (Christmas)", "Sixteen Tons", "Something True", "Think About Your Troubles", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today", "Turn Out the Light", "Who Done It?", "Will She Miss Me", "Woman Oh Woman", "You Can't Do That") B♭2 ("Coconut", "How Long Can Disco On", "I Don't Need You", "I Said Goodbye to Me" Alternate Version, "It Had to Be You", "Lean on Me", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Makin' Whoopee!", "The Most Beautiful World in the World", "One" 1968 Demo, "There Will Never Be", "U.C.L.A.") A2 ("I Guess the Lord Must Be in New York City", "It's a Jungle Out There", "Mucho Mungo/Mt. Elga", "One", "Who Done It?", " Without Her") G♯2 ("All My Life", "Good Old Desk", "Sail Away", "(Thursday) Here's Why I Didn't Go to Work Today") G2 ("All I Think About Is You", "Always", "At My Front Door", "Daddy's Song", "Growin' Up", "Love Story (You and Me)", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "Mournin' Glory Story", "Old Bones", "Puget Sound", " The Lottery Song", " This Is All I Ask", " The Wailing of the Willow", "Who Done It?", "Without Her") F♯2 ("Growin' Up", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "Makin' Whoopee!") F2 ("Home", "Laughin' Man", " Save the Last Dance for Me", "U.C.L.A.", "The Wailing of the Willow", "What's Your Sign?", "You Made Me Love You") E2 (" Hi-Heel Sneakers/Rescue Boy Medley", "I Never Thought I'd Get This Lonely", "Lullaby in Ragtime", "The Moonbeam Song", " Old Forgotten Soldier") E♭2 (" Old Bones") D2 ("I Don't Need You") C♯2 (" I Think I'm Getting Old") C2 ("Take 54", " Who Done It?") {Questionable Notes}A6 ("Daylight" [1])
G♯6 ("Daylight" [5])
F♯5 ("How to Write a Song" [3])
C2 ("What's Your Sign?" [1])
.......................................................
[1] marks yelps and short trills in high range or anacrusis and short dips in low range.
[2] marks notes of questionable identity that cannot be confirmed to be the singer in question.
[3] marks non-melodic notes that don't have a significant enough pitch to warrant inclusion.
[4] marks notes that possess uncertain pitch or have been pitch-shifted.
[5] marks notes that do not fit the previous criteria but are not of a substantial enough quality to warrant counting towards the singer's range. .......................................................
Blue marks falsetto or whistle notes.
Green marks harsh and distorted notes.
Underlines mark notes that are obscured in the song mix.
Italics mark non-melodic notes.
Boldface marks notes that are considered to be particularly notable examples of this person's vocal capabilities.The thread definitely has some issues, the errors with pitching, alphabetization, too many bolds, are all fair. But still, it's this guy's first thread. The extremities, if they're countable (of which I think the G#6 is fine honestly, but not the A6), shouldn't be that big of an issue. Plus, it's his thread to do with what he wishes (and I think he's sharing it?) So you don't need to be so aggressive to the guy. If there are serious issues just point them out with some examples, you don't need to say "your thread is terrible, but thankfully I fixed it with the help of a friend of mine, now use the thread that we made." |
|
|
|
Post by SailorBlue on Jan 5, 2022 17:35:48 GMT
Roman I know it's a messy thread but it's the man's first thread if your just Gonna hate on someone's first thread at least make some good comments about it I already did, but that was before he went out of his way to count the A6 after I explicitly told him not to. I wouldn't call it hate either, as all I said were valid criticisms. Could I have phrased it better? Sure. But is it needless hate that serves no purpose? No. The thread definitely has some issues, the errors with pitching, alphabetization, too many bolds, are all fair. But still, it's this guy's first thread. The extremities, if they're countable (of which I think the G#6 is fine honestly, but not the A6), shouldn't be that big of an issue. Plus, it's his thread to do with what he wishes (and I think he's sharing it?) So you don't need to be so aggressive to the guy. If there are serious issues just point them out with some examples, you don't need to say "your thread is terrible, but thankfully I fixed it with the help of a friend of mine, now use the thread that we made." Unless there's a good reason this can justify that he can control his voice up to the G# and in between. Then the note goes in the bin. I'll concede to the fact that I didn't know he was 15 years old and was needlessly harsh. But I still stand behind the core of what I said. (It also took me hours to fully redux the thread so cut me some slack here) |
|
|
|
Post by rob on Jan 5, 2022 18:08:35 GMT
If the G# is good on its own merits then I think that's all there is to it. This singer just might not have utilized his super high range very much by choice. Granted, I haven't listened to his stuff really, so I could be completely off base.
I respect the dedication to take the time to remake the thread, but at the same time, nobody asked you to, right? Please correct me if I'm wrong about that, but if I'm not wrong, then it just comes off a bit strange to put in all the work instead of just explaining a few of the issues.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Post by innuendo on Jan 5, 2022 19:47:32 GMT
I wouldn't count the A6 (it's brief and sounds inhaled to me), but I'd count the G#6 since is clearer and less brief than the A6. And I would say that the C6 should be blue.
Just my opinion anyway.
|
|
