Paul McCartney (37,690 views)

[Ian]

Nov 24, 2021 19:44:19 GMT rob said:

Nov 24, 2021 18:14:57 GMT Ian said:

And? Why does it matter when the post was made? I was simply providing an update.

I think it's mostly about the way you phrased it. If you had said, "Can we also add McCartney III since it was released last year" it would come off more as you seemingly intended, and not as trying to correct a comment from before the album came out. At least that's my perspective, maybe I misunderstood something, if I did I'm sorry.

Yeah, I probably could've phrased it better. Sorry about that.

[rob]

Nov 25, 2021 18:38:17 GMT Ian said:

Nov 24, 2021 19:44:19 GMT rob said:

I think it's mostly about the way you phrased it. If you had said, "Can we also add McCartney III since it was released last year" it would come off more as you seemingly intended, and not as trying to correct a comment from before the album came out. At least that's my perspective, maybe I misunderstood something, if I did I'm sorry.

Yeah, I probably could've phrased it better. Sorry about that.

All good my guy, intent is always quite difficult to tell over text. No harm done either way I think.

[Ian]

What about this falsetto in a live performance of Twist and Shout? www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6qIrZFAp6Y&t=51s&ab_channel=PavelChumlen

[d carcosa]

Ima just count it tbh, not gon wait until january just to watch it

[Ian]

Sept 29, 2019 22:59:27 GMT Holsety said:

"Soily" live Wings over America

I think this should be bolded.

Edit: Just put the rest of my bold suggestions on the next post.

[Ian]

Here are all of my bold suggestions:

Sept 29, 2019 22:59:27 GMT Holsety said:

B5 ("The Hippy Hippy Shake" live at the BBC Vol. 1)

Sept 29, 2019 22:59:27 GMT Holsety said:

Bb5 ("Hey Jude")

Sept 29, 2019 22:59:27 GMT Holsety said:

Eb5 ("Soily" live Wings over America)

[mehrhs9]

I still do not fully understand why his e6 in I Love This House is not countable

[innuendo]

Feb 15, 2022 20:48:47 GMT Ian said:

Here are all of my bold suggestions:

Sept 29, 2019 22:59:27 GMT Holsety said:

B5 ("The Hippy Hippy Shake" live at the BBC Vol. 1)

Sept 29, 2019 22:59:27 GMT Holsety said:

Bb5 ("Hey Jude")

Sept 29, 2019 22:59:27 GMT Holsety said:

Eb5 ("Soily" live Wings over America)

I actually wouldn't bold the Bb5 in Hey Jude. It's a very good note, but I don't think it matches Twist And Shout A5, which is "just" a semitone lower

[Ian]

Feb 16, 2022 19:46:23 GMT mehrhs9 said:

I still do not fully understand why his e6 in I Love This House is not countable

I completely think it should be counted. I think the reason was because he wasn’t hitting the note consistently (which is an absolute bullshit reason if you ask me).

[ellie]

Ayo chill

[Holsety]

I'll address my response to both John and Paul's threads here:

I have no intention of updating these threads and I stand by my bold choices. I won't be accounting for the ever-changing standards of the forum. If it warrants a restart, then I'd prefer if a staff member familiar with their voices did so.

['S]

I can't really point to anything of substance that has changed with standards since you were staff or even since two years ago. Unless sarcasm and in that case I did laugh and I would probably write the same thing at this point lol :love:

[Ian]

Jul 25, 2020 16:19:27 GMT BAZanine said:

Absolutely epicest low note of Paul's sorry career: youtu.be/81WwGlbVcBg?t=3m6s

Here’s the epicest high notes of Paul’s career: youtu.be/MXz41IZ-ZQY

[chimmychupa]

G4, A4, B4, C5,

[EddieCheivz]

I Think there's a D2 here; humming "Bourree in E Minor" melody:

[Osmosis]

Think there is a G5 at the very end of "Band on the Run". Could be a guitar but I don't think it is. Sounds very Paul to me.
 
Edit: And the note isn't present in the official instrumental versions found on youtube so it is definitely Paul

[BAZanine]

I think the C5 from the One Hand Clapping version of "Nineteen Hundred and Eighty Five" could be bolded:

Some E♭5s from this performance as well.

[Henny Macc]

Amazed that I managed to find some notes that this thread missed!

He does the A5 scream instead of John in the intro here, sings the falsetto E♭5s on the chorus with John at 0:44, sings some B4s at 0:48 in between lines of the chorus, does what sounds like a quiet E5 scream at 2:02 followed by I think a quick G♭5 at 2:07, sings an A4 harmony on the verse line at 2:14, and belts up to some D5s at 3:04!

[Osmosis]

Is there a staff member willing to step forward and sift through and update this thread with all these new found notes? 

[Henny Macc]

I nominate TheRealRomanHeath

[Subterranean Homesick Ålien]

Do you ever just find yourself staring at a wall, thinking “Paul hit higher full notes than Mariah Carey, and lower notes than Frank Sinatra…
He legitimately might be The Messiah” ?

[Steingrim]

Sept 28, 2022 14:31:03 GMT Subterranean Homesick Ålien said:

Do you ever just find yourself staring at a wall, thinking “Paul hit higher full notes than Mariah Carey, and lower notes than Frank Sinatra…
He legitimately might be The Messiah” ?

No, that would be that dude who finds a piano in a shopping mall and then makes sounds that emulate all the keys. What was his name again ? I can't seem to remember. 

[Henny Macc]

Sept 28, 2022 14:31:03 GMT Subterranean Homesick Ålien said:

Do you ever just find yourself staring at a wall, thinking “Paul hit higher full notes than Mariah Carey, and lower notes than Frank Sinatra…
He legitimately might be The Messiah” ?

[mrchonghead]

now that is a throwback to trp2 oh my word

[Subterranean Homesick Ålien]

I guess not.