Jack Black (22,307 views)

[Baronessa]

Jun 30, 2021 23:03:25 GMT IhateMana said:

"Pat Riley" doesn't actually sound like it genuinely hits G1, I don't think there's really much tone there when he goes below C#2, and that the "G1" is primarily an A1 with very little tone
"Chad Gadya" is only around A1/Bb1, but it's mostly a breathy trail-down that imo isn't really much of anything
"Simply Jazz" does hit G1, but it's nowhere near as strong or carrying as much tone as the A1s and I'd probably be iffy about counting it myself

Just popping in to say I agree with this take. Although seems like he gets down to A1 just fine a little earlier in "Pat Riley".

[Goober]

Regarding this D7

"Idk man the notesgood
Fuck range gaps just do it
I havent geard it but liek
I want you." - Bazanine

quite a lot of people on discord seem to think it's countable (and on the forum it seems), also he made it a habit to perform that note consistently throughout the late 90s - early 2000s

Here are the other notes if you're interested.
youtu.be/nG1VrtmJhVg?t=208
youtu.be/xWh_s2Ox4GE?t=1180
youtu.be/YmHvf0C8hLc?t=729
youtu.be/Nh_-coPDFpc?t=55
www.reddit.com/r/LiveFromNewYork/comments/vn66hj/a_prefamous_tenacious_d_appearing_as_a_credited/ 1:40
youtu.be/3XHGI_DKx58?t=75 link to the demo note

These are notably worse, but whatevs

[Homelander]

Dec 30, 2023 1:35:17 GMT Goober said:

Regarding this D7

"Idk man the notesgood
Fuck range gaps just do it
I havent geard it but liek
I want you." - Bazanine

quite a lot of people on discord seem to think it's countable (and on the forum it seems), also he made it a habit to perform that note consistently throughout the late 90s - early 2000s

Here are the other notes if you're interested.
youtu.be/nG1VrtmJhVg?t=208
youtu.be/xWh_s2Ox4GE?t=1180
youtu.be/YmHvf0C8hLc?t=729
youtu.be/Nh_-coPDFpc?t=55
www.reddit.com/r/LiveFromNewYork/comments/vn66hj/a_prefamous_tenacious_d_appearing_as_a_credited/ 1:40
youtu.be/3XHGI_DKx58?t=75 link to the demo note

These are notably shittier, but whatevs

I know this probably hurts your argument, but I agree with you.

[Baronessa]

Okay, so I had a few non-4 AM thoughts about the D7.

The main argument in favour of including a D7 seems to be that he's aiming for something around that pitch each time, and since he's done it multiple times we can assume that he does know how to do whistle register. Even if he can't really do a melody he can at least hit a D7. But there's a key thing missing here and that's even one example of him cleanly hitting a D7. Even if he'd only hit it once that would be at least something we could point to as a 'smoking gun', but since we seem to be missing a note like that it would not be up to standard to use any of those links as an example of him hitting a D7 in the main section.

We're sort of working backwards from our conclusion here, if you get me. We should be looking at a cleanly executed D7 and looking for examples to support its inclusion, as opposed to finding a bunch of bad D7s in order to support our assumption that he could theoretically hit a good D7.

[Captain Planet]

I just listened to all those live notes and the way he starts the notes on a very screechy pterodactyl-esque sound makes me suspicious. As the inhale policeman here I feel compelled to say those are inhaled! (not that anyone will believe me).

[Baronessa]

He takes a breath in right before he hits them, so I would say they are at least not inhaled.

[Goober]

Dec 28, 2023 0:49:38 GMT Goober said:

youtu.be/UjcPeMCWOAw?t=156 I suggest you go through this entire thing, great notes, some really good lows at 3:19
youtu.be/tPFvHA_DwuY?t=2239 goes on for a little bit
youtu.be/tPFvHA_DwuY?t=1085 crazy good high here.

Bumping these up, also youtu.be/BH35ahbWO_E?t=509 Tribute G5 here

[crack]

[Kreuger]

Is it me or does his voice sound odd in that? Dont get me wrong, I loved it.

[Gilad]

Yeah his voice is pitch corrected to hell which gives it a bit of a synthetic sound. But it's Jables so his personality shines through and makes up for it

[Homelander]

I thought it was pretty good, actually.

[Kreuger]

Theres now a full version.

youtu.be/abz-YvKjLgY

[123]

www.youtube.com/shorts/nO8Nzu7PaCk
Do random youtube shorts count that I found while scrolling?! He has a falsetto G#4 regardless...

[Macca]

Apr 14, 2024 1:33:16 GMT 123 said:

www.youtube.com/shorts/nO8Nzu7PaCk
Do random youtube shorts count that I found while scrolling?! He has a falsetto G#4 regardless...

I already posted that one, including 2 other ones of those.