Bands we've notewatched (12,797 views)

[Macca]

Mar 13, 2024 21:18:43 GMT Henny Macc said:

What bands on the list have only one member with a thread?

Kinda don’t feel like checking through them all but there’s quite a few on there

[Henny Macc]

Well I just went through the list and I found four instances of such entries - Mairéad Ní Mhaonaigh from Altan, Carly Simon from The Simon Sisters, Órla Fallon from Celtic Woman, and Toni Tennille from Captain & Tenille.

Of those four artists, the only one that I could find a thread for another member of on here was Celtic Woman, for which it turns out we also have a Chloë Agnew thread. I went ahead and added her to their section, and it now fits that criteria by that means. The other three I could find no other member threads for though, so I deleted them from the list.

For the record I also don't remember adding any of those artists myself, and I noticed that all four were threads by 'S, so I'm not sure if maybe they've been editing the OP unbeknownst to me to add some of their own stuff. If so, I don't mind, but it's worth understanding and keeping in mind how the format and criteria works so we don't screw up the flow of the list like this.

[Macca]

Mar 14, 2024 5:05:15 GMT Henny Macc said:

Well I just went through the list and I found four instances of such entries - Mairéad Ní Mhaonaigh from Altan, Carly Simon from The Simon Sisters, Órla Fallon from Celtic Woman, and Toni Tennille from Captain & Tenille.

Of those four artists, the only one that I could find a thread for another member of on here was Celtic Woman, for which it turns out we also have a Chloë Agnew thread. I went ahead and added her to their section, and it now fits that criteria by that means. The other three I could find no other member threads for though, so I deleted them from the list.

For the record I also don't remember adding any of those artists myself, and I noticed that all four were threads by 'S , so I'm not sure if maybe they've been editing the OP unbeknownst to me to add some of their own stuff. If so, I don't mind, but it's worth understanding and keeping in mind how the format and criteria works so we don't screw up the flow of the list like this.

What about the 2NE1 one.

['S]

Turns out on 21 Jan last year I made an edit to fix spoiler spacing, and put into the OP a band member from a Platypus thread amongst three others of mine, I didn't remember telling Henny Macc but turns out we did exchange private messages on Discord. Fwiw all those singers could qualify if/when another band member gets a thread so it's still a possibility (the possible exception being C&T since Toni's sisters were official-unofficial members, were there in all their 1974-1979 tours and television appearances as well as all their A&M albums, sometimes as a like subgroup trio 'The Tennille Sisters' with Toni, all enough to have had threads done for them in 2016, blah blah blah).

[Henny Macc]

Mar 14, 2024 7:04:49 GMT Macca said:

Mar 14, 2024 5:05:15 GMT Henny Macc said:

Well I just went through the list and I found four instances of such entries - Mairéad Ní Mhaonaigh from Altan, Carly Simon from The Simon Sisters, Órla Fallon from Celtic Woman, and Toni Tennille from Captain & Tenille.

Of those four artists, the only one that I could find a thread for another member of on here was Celtic Woman, for which it turns out we also have a Chloë Agnew thread. I went ahead and added her to their section, and it now fits that criteria by that means. The other three I could find no other member threads for though, so I deleted them from the list.

For the record I also don't remember adding any of those artists myself, and I noticed that all four were threads by 'S , so I'm not sure if maybe they've been editing the OP unbeknownst to me to add some of their own stuff. If so, I don't mind, but it's worth understanding and keeping in mind how the format and criteria works so we don't screw up the flow of the list like this.

What about the 2NE1 one.

Oh yeah, good catch - I missed that one. Fixed now.

Mar 14, 2024 11:56:01 GMT 'S said:

Turns out on 21 Jan last year I made an edit to fix spoiler spacing, and put into the OP a band member from a Platypus thread amongst three others of mine, I didn't remember telling Henny Macc but turns out we did exchange private messages on Discord. Fwiw all those singers could qualify if/when another band member gets a thread so it's still a possibility (the possible exception being C&T since Toni's sisters were official-unofficial members, were there in all their 1974-1979 tours and television appearances as well as all their A&M albums, sometimes as a like subgroup trio 'The Tennille Sisters' with Toni, all enough to have had threads done for them in 2016, blah blah blah).

That's right, I remember that now. I didn't realize the bands you were adding were ones that had only singular members documented though, otherwise I would've said something.

If/when those other members get threads, we can definitely add them though! Until then, however, I'm not really about adding entries for bands that we *could* have threads for other members of though, because if we did that the list would just be freaking endless.

[Macca]

Here's a band to add

SPOILER: Click to show

{Spice Girls}Melanie C
Emma Bunton
Mel B
Geri Halliwell
Victoria Beckham

[tylerhelt]

What about The Dave Clark Five. Mike Smith could be added.